Maybe I Was Wrong
Victoria’s POV
At the mention of Caleb’s name, my eyes instinctively drifted across the table, landing on Nova.
86
65 vouchers
She had been unusually quiet all morning. While the rest of us were laughing, throwing bread, and talking about the upcoming events of the vacation, Nova had barely touched the food on her plate.
She sat with her shoulders slightly hunched, staring down at her eggs as if her mind were a million miles
away.
There was a faint, shadowed sadness resting around her eyes that hadn’t been there yesterday.
But what caught my attention even more was Leo. From a couple seats down, Leo was staring at Nova, his brows slightly drawn, watching her with a silent intensity that made my eyes narrow.
“Yeah, where is Caleb?” someone else repeated.
Gradually, all eyes fell on Nova, assuming she would know where he was.
Nova didn’t answer. She was so lost in her own thoughts that she didn’t even seem to realize the entire room had gone quiet, waiting for her to speak.
Adele, sitting right next to her, reached out and gently nudged Nova’s shoulder. “Nova?”
Nova startled violently, her fork clattering loudly against the ceramic plate.
“Oh–I’m sorry!” Nova stammered quickly, her face turning pale as she looked around at the curious faces staring back at her. “I… I was just deep in thoughts. Sorry.”
Coach Miller, sitting at the head of the table near Natasha, lowered his coffee mug and looked at her with a gentle, fatherly frown.
“You okay, kiddo? You look a bit pale.”
“I’m fine, Coach,” Nova assured him, forcing a quick, tight smile that didn’t reach her eyes at all. “Just didn’t sleep very well last night, that’s all.”
She was deliberately avoiding eye contact, her fingers tightly clutching her paper napkin beneath the edge of the table. A knot of unease tightened in my chest.
Something was definitely wrong. Nova was usually so bright, so quick to laugh, but right now she looked like she was holding herself together by a thread.
I made a mental note right then and there to pull her aside after breakfast and find out what was bothering
her.
Natasha leaned forward slightly, her observant gaze scanning Nova’s face.
1/4
14:45 Tue, Aug 18
Do Not Fall For The Baseball Captains
86
55 vouchers
“Are you sure you’re okay, Nova? You don’t have to force yourself to join the games today if you’re feeling under the weather.”
“I’m really fine, Nat, I promise,” Nova insisted, her voice small, though the forced smile remained firmly plastered on her lips.
Natasha nodded slowly, clearly not buying the answer for a single second, but she had the grace not to press the issue in front of a room full of loud people.
Nobody else pushed either, though the easy, carefree atmosphere at the table had dimmed slightly.
Pivoting to give Nova some space, Natasha turned her attention back to the missing team member.
“Do you have any idea where Caleb is, though? Did he mention sleeping in?”
I watched Nova carefully. The moment Caleb’s name was spoken again, her entire posture locked up.
Her throat worked as she opened her mouth to answer, but the words seemed to catch in her throat.
She stuttered, struggling to form a coherent sentence.
“He… he said he was…”
Before she could get the words out, the wooden front door of the cabin swung open.
Caleb walked in, shaking the morning dew off his jacket. But he wasn’t alone.
Stepping through the doorway right behind him, carrying a small designer duffel bag over her shoulder, was the absolute last person anyone in this cabin ever expected to see.
Lexi.
The room went still.
Forks paused halfway to mouths. Conversations died mid–sentence.
One by one, heads turned toward the doorway until every pair of eyes settled on the two figures standing in doorway.
Lexi offered the room a small, tentative smile as she tucked a loose strand of blonde hair behind her ear. She looked effortlessly put together despite what had to have been a long drive.
Caleb stood beside her, shoulders squared, his face giving nothing away at first glance. But the longer I looked, the easier it was to spot the cracks. The tired eyes. The tight jaw. The guilt he couldn’t quite hide beneath his stubborn expression.
A chill crept down my spine as I heard a quiet, shaky breath beside me.
I turned to Nova.
She wasn’t looking at the doorway anymore.
2/4
14:45 Tue, Aug 18
Do Not Fall For The Baseball Captains
គ
86
55 vouchers
Her eyes were fixed on the untouched food in front of her, and her hands sat clasped in her lap, crushing her napkin so tightly her knuckles had turned white.
She was fighting so hard to keep her face completely blank, but the subtle tremor in her chin betrayed every ounce of pain she was trying to hide.
In that single, quiet moment, a whole lot of pieces suddenly clicked into place in my head.
Heat rose in my chest, only to sink into a deep, sickening disappointment.
I stared across the room at Caleb, unable to wrap my head around what I was looking at.
After everything Lexi had put him through–after she had walked away from him when he was lying in a hospital bed with broken bones and a shattered future, after she had left him at his absolute lowest without a second thought–he had gone right back to her.
Not only had he taken her back into his life, but he had the audacity to invite her to a private team trip, parading her in front of the very people who had watched him fall apart because of her.
And he had done it right in front of Nova.
My eyes stayed on him, searching for the boy I’d known for most of my life.
For fifteen years, Caleb had been my best friend. I’d always believed he had a good heart, even when he made terrible decisions.
But sitting here now, watching Nova silently fall apart while he stood beside Lexi…
I wasn’t so sure anymore.
Had he always been this selfish?
Or had I just never wanted to call it for what it was?
3/4
14:45 Tue, Aug 18
Do Not Fall For The Baseball Captains

Comments
The readers' comments on the novel: Do Not Fall For The Baseball Captains (Victoria and Elijah)