Victoria’s POV
“Don’t go,” he murmured, his voice dropping into a rough whisper.
His breath was hot against my neck, a heavy mix of top–shelf whiskey, faint wintergreen mint, and cigarette smoke.
It should have been repulsive. I should have turned my nose up at it. But instead, it acted like a direct narcotic to my brain. It was a sick, intoxicating turn–on.
If Caleb’s hot–and–cold routine was making me crazy, Elijah was turning me into a complete psycho.
Why on earth was I finding the smell of vice and liquor so deeply arousing?
“I love the feeling of your body on mine,” he growled, his large hand sliding up my back, his long fingers tangling into the strands of my hair to tilt my head back.
I let out a shaky breath, instinctively trying to turn my face away from his intense gaze.
I squeezed my eyes shut, a small, bitter line forming between my brows as I shook my head against his hand.
I couldn’t handle him looking at me like that when I felt so incredibly plain, so entirely unworthy of that kind of hunger. It felt like a cruel trick, even if he didn’t mean it to be. Elijah noticed the shift instantly. His fingers tightened gently in my hair, his thumb coming up to catch my chin and forcing my face back up to his.
The lazy, drunken haze in his eyes vanished, replaced by a sudden, fierce seriousness that pinned me to his chest.
“Look at me, Victoria,” he commanded, his voice dropping into a deeper, raw register that made my chest ache.
“Stop hiding from me. I mean it. You are gorgeous.”
This time, the raw conviction in his voice broke through my defenses. I believed him.
A hot, stinging tear slipped from the corner of my eye, wet against my cheek.
“Wh… why do you think so?” I whispered, hatefully vulnerable.
He let out a low chuckle, a sound that vibrated directly against my chest.
“Think?”
In one smooth, heavy motion, he rolled his hips, flipping our positions so effortlessly that my head barely had time to register the shift before I was flat on my back against the pillows, and his massive frame was looming directly over me.
His heavy thighs slotted perfectly between mine, and I could feel the massive, thick
Between My Legs
ridge of his hard dick rubbing directly against my aching, wet pussy through our layers of clothing.
! let out a soft, broken gasp, my eyes fluttering shut as the friction sent a white–hot spark straight to my core.
“Elijah…”
“I don’t think you’re beautiful, Tori. You just are,” he murmured, his dark eyes fixed on
mine.
His eyes tracked the way my lips had parted, thirsty for his mouth.
He reached up, his knuckles brushing against my cheek as his fingers gently hooked around the frames of my glasses, sliding them off my face and setting them blindly on the nightstand.
He leaned in closer, staring intensely into my face without the barrier of the lenses. “I love how innocent you look behind those frames, but without them… your eyes are incredible. They’re this deep, startling shade of sapphire that completely cuts right through me. You have the prettiest face, Victoria, framed by all this soft brown hair, but it’s these lips…”
His gaze dropped, his thumb coming up to trace my unconsciously parted bottom lip. “…and the fire you’re hiding underneath it all that drives me crazy. I see the heat in you. And I want to be the one who unlocks it. I want to watch you burn wild.”
His words were raw, visceral, and completely stripped of any filter.
As he spoke, he began to slowly slide his hips down, deliberately grinding the heavy, thick length of his dick right against my aching center.
The pressure was agonizingly perfect.
I arched my back slightly, an unholy whimper escaping my throat as the friction sent a heavy, liquid pulse of arousal straight down my spine.
I was completely consumed.
Elijah was drunk enough to lose his restraint, and it made him incredibly predatory. He leaned down, his mouth finally capturing mine in a deep kiss.
His tongue slid into my mouth, tasting heavily of alcohol and mint, demanding a `response.
I met his tongue with my own, my hands moving up to grip the damp muscles of his shoulders, pulling him down harder against me.
His hands were everywhere, tracing the curves of my waist, sliding down to squeeze my ass through my shorts, lifting my hips so he could grind harder against my soaking
wetness.
Between My Legs
Every touch felt electric, hot, and heavy.
Slowly, his mouth left mine, tracing a path of burning kisses down my jawline, over the sensitive skin of my throat, and down to the collar of my shirt.
He pulled the fabric down, his teeth lightly grazing my shoulder before his head moved lower.
The tip of his nose trailed down my stomach until he stopped right at the elastic waistband of my underwear, his hot breath billowing against the exposed skin of my lower belly.
He looked up at me from between my legs, his dark eyes asking for the final permission to strip me bare.
“Can I?” he rasped.
My cunt was literally throbbing, slick and soaking wet, practically begging for his touch.
I couldn’t speak, so I just nodded my head against the pillow, my fingers digging into his shoulders.
But instead of pulling my underwear down, Elijah suddenly stopped.
A smirk spread across his lips as he slowly leaned back, resting his forearms on either side of my waist, looking down at me with a lazy, challenging glint in his eyes.
“Our contract doesn’t say anything about intimacy, Victoria,” he pointed out, his voice smooth and dripping with irony.
I felt a sudden, burning flush of intense embarrassment hit my cheeks.
He was repeating the exact words I had thrown in his face weeks ago when he had tried to kiss me.
I immediately snapped my head to the side, refusing to look at him as my face burned with humiliation.
I tried to pull my legs together, but his thighs were locking mine open. He let out a low, amused chuckle at my reaction.
“Maybe… maybe we can revise the contract,” I blurted out, the words leaving my mouth before my brain could even stop them.
The second the sentence hung in the air, I wanted to choke. It sounded incredibly desperate, completely revealing how badly I wanted him inside me.
“I… I mean, I didn’t mean it like-”
Elijah’s smirk softened, and he reached up, gently cupping my burning cheeks in his large hands, forcing me to look back into his dark eyes.
“I may be drunk, Victoria, but I definitely know exactly what I’m doing right now,” he said, his tone turning surprisingly steady, almost protective.
Between My Leg:
“I won’t lure you or seduce you into a bed when I’m half–conscious, and I won’t let you make a decision you’ll regret tomorrow just because you’re feeling horny. If you want to take me, or if you want more of this… we do it when you have a completely clear head, and when I’m sober enough to remember every single sound you make.”
I stared up at him, my lips parted in absolute astonishment.
The intense sexual fog in my brain cleared just enough for a profound confusion to
take over.
“You… you completely confuse me sometimes, Elijah,” I whispered honestly.
He raised a single dark eyebrow, his thumb brushing over my lower lip.
“How so?”
“Considering who you are… you’re incredibly rich, handsome, the best athlete on this campus, and everyone knows how smart you are. I expected the absolute worst from you when we started this. I thought you were just a heartless, privileged jock. And yeah, sometimes you are incredibly annoying, controlling, arrogant, and completely insufferable. But times without number, you’ve shown up for me. You’ve protected me when you had no reason to. Your reputation on campus didn’t look pleasant at all, but you aren’t who they say you are.”
Elijah just stared down at me for a long, quiet beat, his dark eyes scanning my face as if searching for something.
Then, the corners of his lips cracked into a genuine, tired smile.
He leaned in close, his forehead briefly resting against mine before he slowly pulled his weight off my body, letting the cool air of the room hit my sensitized skin.
“Don’t believe everything you hear about the devil, Victoria,” he murmured, his voice laced with a strange, dark cynicism that left me completely puzzled and perplexed.
“Sometimes he just needs people to stay afraid so they don’t look too closely at the scars.”
Before I could ask him what on earth that meant, he stood up from the bed, his tall frame swaying slightly as he staggered out of the bedroom area and toward the small kitchen, leaving me shivering on the mattress, completely undone and entirely out of my depth.
Why Didn’t it Feel Right?

Comments
The readers' comments on the novel: Do Not Fall For The Baseball Captains (Victoria and Elijah)