Jordan had never liked making his girlfriend wait.
Whether he was picking her up for work, returning a stolen kiss in passing, or answering some earnest question she’d asked him, he’d always been quick to respond.
And yet now, with Aren sitting before him, her thighs parted in unmistakable invitation, he found himself strangely incapable of making the next move.
’How am I actually supposed to touch her there?’
His gaze drifted toward the space between her thighs.
’Should I ask her what she likes?’
’No, God. That’ll make me sound like I have absolutely no idea what I’m doing.’
Unfortunately, that was becoming increasingly accurate.
’What if I do something wrong and make her uncomfortable? What if she thinks I’m only interested in having sex with this body now that I know it isn’t hers?’
That last thought troubled him more than the others.
He’d rehearsed this situation in his head more times than he would ever admit, and those fantasies had always gone smoothly. Imaginary Jordan had apparently possessed unlimited confidence, perfect instincts, and none of the inconvenient emotional complications currently strangling the real one.
Reality, it turned out, was much less cooperative.
Aren was right there — warm, real, watching him with trusting eyes.
After everything she’d just confessed about who she truly was, Jordan suddenly felt as though every touch carried meaning, and he didn’t want to get that meaning wrong.
After a while, Aren noticed his hesitation.
’Why isn’t he... touching me?’
At first, she’d assumed he was simply taking his time. But several seconds passed, then several more, and the hand that had been moving so confidently earlier remained motionless against her thigh.
Meanwhile, the ache between her legs was becoming increasingly difficult to ignore. When she drew back slightly from their kiss and studied his face, she noticed the faint tension between his brows.
’Oh.’
’He doesn’t know what to do first.’
She remembered how nervous he’d been at the museum, how he’d confessed his inexperience despite clearly fearing what she might think of him. Perhaps this wasn’t so different.
’Maybe I should help him.’
With shy determination, she laid her hand over his. Her fingers trembled only a little as she guided him higher, until his fingertips brushed directly over her pussy through the fabric of her jeans.
"There... Jordan."
Her voice was soft and embarrassed, but certain.
"I like it there."
Her sudden boldness stole the breath from his lungs.
"...Aren."
His throat tightened.
"Aren... are you sure?"
"Yes."
Her cheeks were warm, but she held his gaze.
"I’m very sure. Don’t you... want to?"
Jordan almost laughed in disbelief. He wanted her so badly that his cock had been aching against his trousers for several minutes now.
"...Of course I want to."
He might have sounded steady, but inside, he was clinging to every scrap of composure he had.
’All right. Calm down.’
’You’re the older one here. You’re supposed to be taking care of her, not making her take care of you.’
’You can do this.’
His thumb began to move in small, tentative circles over the fabric covering her pussy.
The first few movements were so cautious that Aren almost smiled. Yet as he continued, she found herself responding to even the slightest shift of his hand.
Her fingers tightened against the sofa.
Her lashes fluttered.
A soft sound escaped her, breathy and surprised, and Jordan felt it go through him like a spark.
"Mm... Yes, Jordan." Her hips shifted helplessly beneath his hand. "Like that."
Her soft encouragement did wonders for his confidence. He kept the motion slow, watching for every sign of how she felt — the way her thighs tensed, then eased open again.
Each circle drew another sound from her, softer than a moan at first, then higher, more unguarded, until his cock throbbed so painfully that he had to swallow back a curse.
’Oh God.’
’Fuck me.’
In one sense, it still felt strange to look at her face and know it belonged to someone else. Somewhere in the back of his mind, he was still trying to imagine what his girlfriend had looked like before she’d inhabited this body.
Rougher skin, she’d said.
Scars from fieldwork.
A face she’d apparently considered unremarkable.
He found himself wanting to know that face. Yet looking at her now, he also found it increasingly difficult to separate the woman he’d come to love from the expressions he’d grown accustomed to seeing.
That shy little smile was hers.
That particular blush was hers.
So was the careful, earnest way she watched him, as if every touch meant more than touch alone.
Only now, there was something more dangerous threaded through it.
She looked turned on.
Very turned on.
Her features had tightened with pleasure. Her eyes had gone glassy. Her breathing had grown uneven, and the sight made him feel more aroused than he’d ever been in his life.
He wanted more.
He wanted to hear her lose that soft restraint completely. Wanted to feel her tremble under his hand, to hear her whisper his name, to watch her come undone because of him.
Yet the harder he tried to decide how to do all of that, the less capable he became of doing anything at all.
’Hold on.’
’I can’t rush this.’
He forced himself to breathe.
’I can’t just strip her and start doing whatever I want.’
’Not after what she just told me.’
’She might think I’m only lusting after this body all over again. I have to make sure she knows I love her, not this body. But how do I even—’
The thought was cut mercilessly short.
Aren had noticed his hesitation again, and this time, she didn’t reach to guide his hand.
She reached for the button of her jeans. Without warning — and to Jordan’s entirely unprepared horror — she undid it and pulled down the zipper.
His shoulders jerked.
"Aren!"
His hand shot out to stop her.
"Aren, Aren... w-what are you doing?"
She looked at him, genuinely confused.
"I’m getting these out of the way."
Apparently finding that explanation sufficient, she shifted her hips, trying to push her jeans down.
"It’ll be much easier for you to move your hands."
Before he could object — or recover enough sense to pull the zipper back up — Aren hooked her fingers into the waistband and pushed her jeans down over her hips. Within seconds, she’d slipped them off and tossed them onto the floor.
Jordan opened his mouth.
No words emerged.
For a man already struggling to maintain some semblance of restraint, the sight was almost cruel.
She’d leaned back against the sofa and spread her legs again, and now she was looking at him expectantly, her expression still carrying that earnest willingness to help him figure things out.
And then there were her panties.
White, silky little panties. With tiny daisies scattered across the fabric.
The contrast between those innocent little flowers and the unmistakable invitation of her posture was doing terrible things to both his continued existence and the ache between his legs.
’Oh, God.’
He swallowed hard.
’All the higher powers above.’
’What am I supposed to do with her?’
He drew a breath.
’I need guidance.’
’No, I need oxygen.’
’No, I need to calm the fuck down.’
’I need help.’

Comments
The readers' comments on the novel: Every Mafia's Favorite Girl
Excellent novel! Highly recommend reading. ✨️...
So, Caio had a full-on sexual relationship with Ariana Lombardi for a while it seems, he supplied her drugs while he used her body. No wonder she was messed up. Now, Aren he wants to own her like some kind of commodity & keep her permanently in his mansion - guilded cage anyone? 🙄🤦♀️...