Caleb’s POV
The courtroom is full, but not the way it was during the trial. Today, every woman sitting in the gallery chose to be here, and that choice weighs more than any verdict ever could.
Rachel sits three rows back, her auburn hair loose around her shoulders, her green eyes fixed on the bench. Jessica is beside her.
Two other women I recognize from the trial sit further down the same row. They are not here as victims. That word does not fit them anymore.
“The court has considered the pre-sentencing report, the victim impact statements, and the totality of circumstances surrounding these offenses,” the judge says.
“On the counts of sexual assault in the first degree, this court sentences the defendant to twelve years in state prison.”
The sound that moves through the gallery is not a cheer. It is a collective exhale — a breath held for months, for years by some of these women, finally released.
“Does the defendant wish to address the court?” the judge asks.
Lucas shakes his head. Handcuffs click shut around his wrists. He stands and walks toward the side door flanked by two officers, and he does not look back at his parents, does not search the gallery for sympathy.
He just walks, head forward, eyes empty, and disappears. The golden boy with the charming smile is gone, replaced by a man who has finally run out of masks to wear.
“Twelve years, Caleb,” Serena says, her hand finding mine under the bench. “It is actually done.”
“Twelve years of locked doors and no one looking the other way for him.” My voice comes out rougher than I expect. “It is done.”
The courtroom empties in clusters and murmurs. Serena kisses my cheek and goes to find William and Catherine, and I linger until the gallery is nearly empty. When I push through the heavy courthouse doors, the spring air hits me warm and green, and Rachel is standing near the base of the steps with her face tilted toward the sky. The sunlight catches the red in her hair and turns it copper. I stop beside her, and we do not embrace.
“How are you feeling?” I ask, settling next to her with my hands in my pockets.
“Like I have been carrying a suitcase for years and someone finally told me I could set it down.” She opens her eyes and looks at me. “What about you? I kept watching your face during the sentencing and I could not read you at all.”
“I kept expecting this huge rush of triumph when the judge read the number, like vindication was supposed to come wrapped in a bow.”
I lean against the stone railing beside her. “Instead I just got quiet, like the ringing in your ears after an explosion stops and you realize you can actually hear the world again.”
“That is closure, Caleb, even if it does not feel the way you expected.” Her voice is gentle but certain. “Sometimes closure is not a crescendo, sometimes it is just the absence of noise.”
“I do not know when you became the wisest person I know, but it is borderline annoying.”
“Two years of therapy will do that to a person.” A faint smile crosses her lips. “You should consider trying it before you grind your teeth down to nothing.”
“Did you see his face when the sentence came down, though? Twenty-two years of everyone looking the other way, and his brain still could not accept that the free pass had an expiration date.”
“The Bennetts built that for him.” There is no bitterness in her voice, just a clear-eyed assessment. “Every lawyer they hired, every accusation they buried, every girl they silenced — they taught him he was untouchable. Then they had the audacity to look shocked when he believed it.”
VERIFYCAPTCHA_LABEL
Comments
The readers' comments on the novel: Hate Me Like You Love Me (Serena and Caleb)