Login via

He Chose My Sister So I Married His Enemy (by Aveline Kryss) novel Chapter 12

Chapter Twelve: Am I The Mistake?

I looked at Damien, waiting for him to deny it.

“That is enough,” he said to the woman, his voice flat and final. He didn’t explain anything beyond that, didn’t tell her she was wrong, didn’t say a single word in his own defense.

She gave me one last look, something close to pity, then walked away without finishing what she’d started.

He had defended me. He hadn’t answered her.

That silence sat heavier than the insult itself.

Damien stayed close as we left, opening the car door for me, making sure I was settled before he walked around to his side. He’d done this same thing after the luncheon at his grandmother’s house, and it had felt like care then. Now it felt like something I couldn’t quite trust, like every careful gesture might just be part of whatever this was.

I thought about the contract. The dress. His grandmother’s warmth, the recipe book, because you were worth choosing. Had any of it been real, or had I simply been the next piece in something that started long before I ever met him?

I knew that fear came from somewhere real. Ethan had said he loved me while building an entire year with my sister behind my back. My own family had smiled at me at that party while already knowing what was coming. Silence, in my experience, usually meant someone was protecting a lie.

The drive started quiet, but it wasn’t the same quiet as before. That silence used to feel safe. This one felt full of everything I didn’t know.

“You’ve gone quiet,” Damien said.

“I’m thinking.”

“About what she said?”

I didn’t answer right away. I stared out the window until the question finally pushed its way out of me. “Was I chosen because of something your grandfather did?”

His expression shifted, but not into anger. Something more careful than that, like he understood exactly why I needed to ask.

“I can survive being part of an arrangement, Damien,” I said quietly. “I cannot survive finding out I was only useful again.”

He pulled the car over without a word, easing it to the side of the road like the conversation mattered more than wherever we’d been heading. He turned fully toward me, and for the first time, nothing about him felt like business.

“You are not his mistake,” he said.

“Then what am I?”

He let the question sit there for a moment before he answered.

1/3

Chooter Twelve. Am The Mistake?

+15 Bonus

“My choice.”

I wanted to believe him completely. I wanted it so badly it scared me. But trust didn’t rebuild itself off one sentence, not after everything that had taught me to expect otherwise.

“Why won’t you tell me what happened?” I asked. “If it has nothing to do with me, why does it matter so much that I don’t know?”

“Because the truth isn’t mine alone to tell,” he said. “It belongs to someone else too. I won’t expose another person’s pain just to make myself look better to you.” He paused. “But nothing in that history changes why I chose you.”

My hands were cold, clenched tightly in my lap without my noticing. He reached over and adjusted the heat without comment, then settled his coat across my knees like it was nothing at all. I didn’t fully relax. But I stopped feeling like I was sitting in that fear alone.

My phone buzzed twice while we sat there. Ethan first.

I should never have let you walk away angry.

Then Ava.

Ethan has been trying to reach you. Whatever game you’re playing, stop hurting him.

I almost laughed at the nerve of it, Ava asking me to manage Ethan’s feelings after spending a year building a life with him behind my back. I deleted her message without a second thought. Ethan’s I left sitting there, unanswered, not because I wanted him back, but because some smaller, older version of me was still allowed to grieve the man she’d believed in for three years.

Damien didn’t ask what the messages said. He didn’t reach for my phone or demand to know. He simply waited, like he understood some things weren’t his to manage either.

When we reached my apartment, he said my name before I could get out.

I turned back.

“You don’t have to believe me today,” he said. Then, quieter, “But I will not let anyone convince you that you are something I regret.”

I sat with that for a moment, surprised by how much it asked of me and how little, all at once. He wasn’t demanding my trust. He was offering to earn it, one quiet sentence at a time.

I carried his coat inside with me, still warm from the car.

An envelope was waiting under my door. No name, no return address.

Inside was a photograph, old enough that the colors had faded slightly. Damien, years younger, stood beside a woman I didn’t recognize. She was smiling at him, and the ease between them caught my attention

immediately. She stood close enough to him to matter.

On the back, in handwriting I didn’t know, someone had written four words.

Ask him why he couldn’t save her.

2/3

I read it twice. My hands had gone cold again, and this time the heat in the car couldn’t reach me.

My phone rang

Damien.

Reading History

No history.

Comments

The readers' comments on the novel: He Chose My Sister So I Married His Enemy (by Aveline Kryss)