Login via

He Chose My Sister So I Married His Enemy (by Aveline Kryss) novel Chapter 3

I didn’t sleep that night.

I lay in bed replaying the same scene over and over. Ethan’s hands in Ava’s hair. The way he looked at her before he answered me. The champagne glass with my ring sinking to the bottom of it. By morning my eyes were swollen and my phone was full of messages I didn’t want to read.

I lost Ethan in one night. The harder truth was realizing I had lost everyone else long before that.

My mother showed up at my apartment around nine, and for one foolish second I let myself hope she had come to hold me. Instead she sat on the edge of my bed and sighed like I was the one causing all the trouble. “Olivia, you need to ease up on your sister. She’s not sleeping either. This isn’t easy for her.”

I stared at her. “Easy for her.”

“She didn’t plan to fall in love with him,” my mother said, like that excused a year of lies. “You stormed out in front of everyone. Do you know how that looks for her?”

I wanted to ask how it looked for me. I didn’t bother. I already knew the answer didn’t matter to her.

My father arrived at my apartment an hour later, and he didn’t ask how I was feeling either. He stood in the doorway with his arms crossed and told me, in a voice meant for boardrooms, that the scandal needed to stay quiet. “People talk, Olivia. This affects the company’s reputation. I need you to keep this contained.”

Contained. Like I was a spill on his office floor.

Nobody was angry at Ethan. Nobody was angry at Ava. The only person anyone seemed angry at was me, for daring to react.

Ava showed up at my apartment that afternoon, eyes red, voice trembling, the picture of a woman destroyed by guilt. “I never meant for it to go this far,” she said, gripping my hands like we were still sisters who told each other the truth. “I tried to stop loving him so many times, Olivia. I really did.”

Then, in the middle of her tears, she said something that told me everything she hadn’t meant to say. “I keep imagining what our wedding will look like. I know that’s selfish to think about right now, but I can’t help it.”

Our wedding. She had already planned it in her head. This wasn’t a moment of weakness. This was a year of building a future on top of the one I thought I had.

I asked her to leave. She left slower than she needed to, like she wanted me to call her back.

I had already called one of the independent firms listed in Damien’s appendix and booked a contract review for later that afternoon. Calling them had somehow made the whole thing feel more real.

Ethan came an hour after that and let himself into my apartment with the key I’d given him when we were still planning to become husband and wife. I hadn’t even thought about changing the lock yet. I added it to the growing list of things I apparently had to rebuild overnight.

“We need to talk,” he said. “Properly. Not like last night.”

“There’s nothing to talk about.”

“Liv, I need you to understand my side of this.” He said it gently, like he was the one owed patience. “It wasn’t supposed to happen the way it did. I know you’re hurt. But I need you to eventually accept it, for everyone’s sake.”

Eventually accept it. Not I’m sorry. Not I was wrong. Just an expectation that I would calm down and let him keep both the life he wanted and the peace he wanted with it.

Then his eyes landed on the folder sitting on my coffee table, Damien’s name visible on the corner of the first page, and his whole face changed. The confidence drained out of him in a way I had never seen before.

“Did he come find you?” Ethan’s voice was suddenly sharp, almost frightened. “Did Damien talk to you? Olivia, what did he say to you?”

I didn’t answer. For the first time since I’d known him, Ethan looked like a man standing too close to something he couldn’t control.

He left without getting his answer. I sat alone in the silence afterward, more confused than before he arrived.

My phone buzzed a few minutes later. One new message. From a number I didn’t recognize, but I knew immediately who it was.

My old sketchbook, one I’d left at Ethan’s apartment years ago, buried among the things I’d gradually moved there while we planned a life together.

“Did Damien mention this?” Ethan asked.

My fingers stopped around my keys. “How do you know he would?”

Ethan’s expression changed. “That’s not the point.”

“Olivia,” he said quietly. “You need to stay away from him.”

I stared at him. Twenty-four hours ago, Ethan had chosen my sister. Now he was standing outside my door warning me about another man.

“Why?” I asked.

His jaw tightened. Then his eyes dropped to the contract still tucked under my arm, and whatever answer he had been about to give died in his throat.

I suddenly realized something.

Ethan wasn’t worried about me.

He was worried about Damien.

The difference mattered.

Reading History

No history.

Comments

The readers' comments on the novel: He Chose My Sister So I Married His Enemy (by Aveline Kryss)