Sofia’s POV
Sofia Knight’s POV
I have been perfect my entire life.
Not almost perfect. Not trying to be perfect. Perfect. Flawlessly, exhaustingly, bone-breakingly perfect.
I trained harder than every girl in the pack. I woke up before sunrise to study the elder texts while the other children were still sleeping. I memorized pack law, bloodline charts, and lunar cycles before I was ten years old.
I smiled when I wanted to scream.
I bowed when I wanted to strike.
I bled quietly in rooms where no one was watching, and I cleaned up the blood before anyone could see.
I was perfect.
And it meant absolutely nothing.
Because Katherine existed.
That’s all she had to do. Exist. She didn’t train. She didn’t study. She didn’t sacrifice a single night of sleep or a single drop of her own comfort.
She just existed-wolf-less, soft, and completely ordinary – and the Moon Goddess handed her everything I had been fighting for since the day I learned how to fight.
The prophecy. The Grey name. The future.
All of it, dropped into Katherine’s lap like a gift she didn’t even know how to open.
I heard from my parents that Agnes had been asking for Katherine since this morning- urgently, desperately, in a way the old woman almost never did.
Agnes didn’t ask for people. People came to her, hat in hand, on their knees. The fact that she was the one reaching out meant she had something to say.
And whatever it was, Katherine was not going to hear it before I did.
The door opened before I even knocked.
Agnes stepped onto the porch, and the moment her clouded, ancient eyes found me standing in the dark, she stopped walking.
—
She didn’t look surprised. She looked the way she always looked like she had already seen this moment coming from a hundred years away and had simply been waiting for it to arrive.
“Sofia.” My name in her mouth sounded like a verdict.
“What are you doing here?” she asked, pulling her shawl tighter against the night air. “It’s past midnight. You should be in your chamber.”
“You’ve been looking for Katherine,” I said, skipping every pretense of politeness. I was done being polite. Polite had gotten me nothing but a front-row seat to my own erasure. “I want to know why.”
Agnes studied me for a long, unbearable moment. “That is between me and your sister.”
1/3
Sofio’s POV
“She isn’t here,” I said. “I am. And I have been here – standing in front of you. So tell me what you were going to tell her.”
“That is not yours to know, child.”
“Child?” The word scraped against something raw inside me. “I am a fully awakened wolf. I have studied very pack law, every lunar text, every bloodline record in this territory. I have bled and trained and sacrificed while Katherine did nothing – not a single thing and yet somehow I am still the child standing outside the door
while she gets handed the future?”
I stepped forward, close enough to see the deep lines carved into Agnes’s ancient face.
“Tell me,” I said, “Why did you choose her instead of me? Why wasn’t it my name you spoke that night? deserve to know. I have earned the right to know.”
Agnes was silent for a moment. The kind of silence that isn’t empty — the kind that’s full of something heavy and
sad.
Then she spoke. “Do you want the truth, Sofia?”
“I have wanted nothing else my entire life.”
Agnes looked at me, and her eyes were not unkind. That almost made it worse.
“You are strong,” she said simply. “Stronger than your sister in almost every way a wolf can be measured. Your wolf is fully awakened. Your instincts are sharp. Your mind is quick. You have gifts Katherine has never had and may never have.”
For one single, treacherous second, something warm flickered in my chest.
Then Agnes continued. “But the Moon Goddess did not ask me to find the strongest daughter.” Her voice was gentle, and it cut like a blade because of it. “She asked me to find the purest. And when I looked at you, the way I see beyond skin and bone and wolf… what I found in your heart was not strength, Sofia.”
She paused.
“It was hunger. Bottomless, burning, consuming hunger. For power. For recognition. For everything you believed was taken from you.” She tilted her head slowly. “A heart like that cannot carry the future of a pack. It will devour it.”
The warmth in my chest died instantly, replaced by something cold and absolute.
“You’re wrong,” I whispered.
“When the Moon Goddess spoke to me that night,” Agnes said, “she told me to look at both Knight daughters. I did. Katherine was wolf-less, fragile, and uncertain. By every measure this pack uses, she was the weaker choice.” A pause. “But her heart was clean. No hunger. No poison. Just love – terrifying amounts of it, for people who would never deserve it.” Something flickered in the old woman’s eyes. “That kind of heart is rare, Sofia. Rarer than a powerful wolf. Rarer than strength. It is the only soil in which a true Alpha heir can grow.”
The silence between us stretched long and awful.
“So that is why,” Agnes said finally. “Not because you weren’t enough. Because you were too much of the wrong thing.”
I stood there, in the dark, on the porch of an old woman who had decided my fate before I was old enough to have a say in it and I felt the last fragile thread of the girl I used to be snap cleanly in two.
2/3
Sofia’s POV
“You ruined my life,” I said. The words came out barely above a whisper, which somehow made them more violent than a scream.
“No, child. I revealed what was already there.”
The words hit me so hard that for a moment I couldn’t breathe.

Comments
The readers' comments on the novel: He Killed Me So I Married His Ruthless Alpha Brother