“Why not?” I asked.
I knew the shape of the answer. I had heard versions of it in Dr. Harper’s office and on his couch one Saturday morning. But I wanted to hear this particular version. The one from tonight, the one that came after three hours of intense conversation.
“Every time someone showed interest,” he said, thought about a dark–haired girl with a sketchbook in her hands, sitting at the kitchen table and drawing the light on a curtain. The girl who looked at me as if I were worth paying attention to.
“Not the soldier. Not the decorated officer. Me. Exactly as I was. The person hiding behind all the distance I kept between myself and everyone else.” He stopped. “I couldn’t find that in anyone else because I wasn’t looking for anyone else.”
I made a small sound.
It was quiet and involuntary, and I was glad he couldn’t see my face.
He heard it.
“I know it isn’t fair to put that on you,” he said. “I know it puts a weight on the past that it shouldn’t have to carry. I’m not saying it to make you feel obligated to do anything.”
“I know,” I said.
“I’m saying it because you asked me, and the honest answer is this.”
I looked at my kitchen wall. Lucy’s drawings. The little watercolor of three figures she had painted in his apartment, with brown eyes rendered in perfect shades.
“It isn’t fair,” I said. “You’re right about that.”
“I know.”
“It’s also,” I said, “probably the most honest thing you’ve ever told me.
A pause.
“Yes,” he said. “I think it probably is.”
I stood in my kitchen, in the silence of an apartment without Lucy, holding the phone and thinking about that dark–haired girl with her sketchbook, and what it meant to be the person someone hadn’t been able to forget for seven years.
I thought about the story I had told myself. That I was easy to leave. That I hadn’t mattered enough for
someone to stay.
I thought about how you could reconcile two things that seemed contradictory: the gravity of what he had done and the truth of what he had felt. Both were true. I understood that now. They didn’t cancel each other out. They simply existed together.
“Good night,” I said.
Chapter 147
+25 BONUS


Comments
The readers' comments on the novel: My Brother's Best Friend's Secret Baby (by Chloe Laurent)