I told myself I could ignore the moans.
I was wrong.
I stared at the horror movie with the focus of someone defusing a bomb, jaw tight, the cushion slowly losing its structural integrity in my grip. The movie wasn’t even scary anymore. Nothing was scarier than the sounds Hannah was making—the kind I’d only ever heard through the apartment walls and wished I hadn’t.
Don’t look, I told myself. Do not look.
I looked.
Hannah was grinding on Matt’s lap. His hand was already moving inside her skirt. Her head was tipped back, her toes curling against the couch, and I watched for approximately one second before my brain sent an urgent message to my eyes that said, Absolutely not.
This is fine, I told myself desperately. This is totally fine.
It was not fine.
The worst part? I couldn’t even blame anyone. At least, not without blaming myself first.
Matt and I had been close friends for four years. Somewhere along the way, friendship stopped being enough for me, but I never found the courage to tell him.
Hannah, who used to be my best friend, knew. Hell, she’d spent months encouraging me to just spit it out, but I always chickened out. I could barely survive being alone in the apartment with him without forgetting how words worked, so after graduation, I introduced him to Hannah and invited her to move in with us.
For company.
For courage. Or at least, that’s what I told myself.
Somewhere between unpacking boxes, late-night takeout, and movie marathons, they fell in love. I never really knew when it happened because by the time Matt sat me down to tell me they were together, all I could do was smile, wish them both well, and wait for the explanation Hannah never gave me.
And now here we were.
Hannah moaned again. Louder this time.
Okay, I’m done here.
I stood. Neither of them noticed. They were too busy trying to share the same mouth.
I walked to my room and banged the door shut, hoping the noise would startle them enough to make them pause or at least acknowledge me. Of course, they didn’t. The moaning continued outside my door.
I dropped my pillow over my face.
This was the only place in the house where I could get any peace, usually, until Hannah decided the walls between our rooms were purely for decoration.
I let out a heavy sigh when a soft knock sounded at my door.
I just knew she was about to make me feel worse.
The door opened before I could answer. Hannah stepped inside with her usual smile, the one that looked warm enough to fool anyone who didn’t know her.
“Julie,” she said softly, her voice carrying that familiar sweetness that had stopped working on me a long time ago.
She walked farther into the room. “I just wanted to say I’m sorry about that. We didn’t mean to make you leave.”
I almost laughed. How predictable. This had already become a routine I hated. She’d push things right to the edge, then come looking for me afterward with an apology that somehow always made me feel worse.
“It’s fine,” I said, hoping she’d leave it there.
She didn’t.
“No, really, it’s not.” Her expression softened just enough to look sincere. “I should be more careful with Matt when you’re around. Sometimes I forget….” She tilted her head. “I forget you still have a thing for him.”
My throat tightened.
I’d been trying very hard not to think about it. I hated how easily she could make me feel embarrassed about something I already felt stupid enough for feeling.
“But here’s the thing, Julie.” She reached for my hand. I pulled my hand back before she could touch it.
“I love him.” Her smile widened “And I think by now it’s pretty obvious he loves me too.” She pressed the word like she wanted to make sure I felt it.
I opened my mouth to say something, but something caught the light.
My gaze dropped to her left hand, where a diamond ring rested on her finger. Large enough that there was no way I’d miss it.
My stomach dropped.
I stared. “Wh-what’s that?” I asked, even though deep down, I already knew. I just didn’t want to believe it.
“Oh, this?” She lifted her hand, turning it just enough for the diamond to sparkle. “Matt proposed.”
For a second, nothing inside me worked. I stumbled back slightly and searched her face for the punchline.
Laugh.
Tell me you’re joking.
Tell me this is some cruel bit you decided to try tonight for fun.
Nothing came. She was serious.
I had always told myself their relationship wouldn’t last. That eventually they’d figure out they weren’t right for each other. That time was on my side even if nothing else was.
Instead, they were getting married.
I smiled.
I don’t know how. But I smiled.
“Congratulations,” I said, not meaning it.




Comments
The readers' comments on the novel: Puck Me Harder, Captain (Julie and Logan)
Any updates????...