Puck Me Harder, Captain
138: Him Over Me?
55 vouchers
I didn’t realize Matt was standing so close to me until my eyes dropped slightly to his lips and I noticed just how close we were. I was about to step back, but before I could, Logan walked into the room.
His eyes moved between me and Matt. At first, he just looked confused, like he was trying to figure out what he was seeing. Then something changed in his face. The confusion disappeared, and suddenly there was this raw anger in his eyes that made my stomach drop.
He crossed the room quickly, grabbed Matt, and pulled him away from me before pushing him against the wall.
“What the fuck, man?” he yelled.
“Logan,” I called.
He looked drunk. I could tell, but not drunk enough that he didn’t know what he was doing. He knew exactly what he was doing, but the alcohol was pushing him to do more than he normally would.
“What do you think you’re doing with my girl?” Logan demanded. “Why the fuck were you trying to get close to her?”
“What are you talking about?” Matt scoffed. “I was just-”
“Trying to kiss her?” Logan cut him off.
Kiss me?
I stepped closer. “No. He was helping me with my eyelash. I had a loose one.” I reached for Logan, but he didn’t even look at me.
“I saw the way you were fucking looking at her today.”
“Logan, stop!”
He still didn’t look at me.
“I saw how badly you wanted her.”
“Logan!” I called again, trying to pull him away from Matt.
Matt barely seemed to react. He was just staring at Logan, like he was trying to understand what he was saying and why he was saying it.
“I don’t get you,” Logan said. “I thought you had respect for me. For her, at least. But even after she told you we’re in love, you didn’t stop trying.”
My heart dropped.
Oh no.
1/5
Puck Me Harder, Captain
55 vouchers
Matt’s face fell. He stared at Logan for a second, like he was still trying to process what he’d just said, before looking at me.
Then he took Logan’s hand off him. So easily. Somehow, seeing how calm Matt was made the whole thing feel even worse.
“What?” His voice came out low
I hated it. I hated the way he looked at me and then back at Logan. This was exactly how I thought he’d react. Only now Logan was standing right there, and he was the one who had told him.
Matt’s eyes stayed on mine, and I tried not to look at him. I really did. But I couldn’t look away now. Not when I could see how much I’d hurt him.
“You and Logan are in love?” he asked.
It didn’t sound like a question. It was more like he was trying to make sure he’d heard him right.
Logan’s eyes moved to me too.
Suddenly, my stomach twisted so hard I thought I was going to be sick.
Logan’s voice dropped “You didn’t tell him, did you?”
“Logan…”
“You told me you told him,”
There was something different in his voice now. The anger was still there, but underneath it was something that hurt even more.
“Why did you lie to me, Julie?”
I didn’t know. I really didn’t. And I felt awful about it.
“I was going to tell him,” I said, stepping closer. “That’s why I came to speak to him. And then you came in
and…”
I stopped.
Because none of it was helping.
Logan didn’t say anything. He just stared at me, complete shock in his eyes.
My eyes were already watering, and I hated myself for making him feel this way. I should’ve just told him from the beginning. I should’ve been honest with him, but I wasn’t. And now whatever alcohol had been clouding his eyes was gone. He was looking at me clearly now, and all he could see was what I’d done.
“Logan, I…” I started again, but he shook his head.
“You care about his feelings more than mine.”
2/5
18:51 Mon, Sep 28
Puck Me Harder, Captain
“That’s not true.”
31
55 vouchers
“You were so worried about how he’d feel that you didn’t even think about what it would do to me.” He said it like he couldn’t believe it.
He was right.
I hated that he was right.
But I didn’t care about Matt more than I cared about Logan. I didn’t. I loved Logan. I just… I didn’t know how to tell Matt about it. But now I wished I’d just done it.
Logan didn’t wait for me to say anything. He turned around and walked out of the room.
“Logan, listen to me.” My heart raced as I hurried after him, but he didn’t stop. He just kept walking.
I reached the door and looked back at Matt.
He was still standing there, and the look on his face made me feel awful all over again. His eyes met mine, and for a second, I wanted to go back and say something. Anything.
But what was I supposed to say?
I looked away and followed Logan down the stairs.
“Logan, wait.”
He kept walking.
We reached the living room, where the party was still loud, but he didn’t stop. People started looking at us as we walked through the crowd, but Logan didn’t seem to notice. He just pushed past them and headed for the
exit.
“Really? You’re just going to walk away from me and go home?”
By the time I reached him, he was already standing by the car. The music from the party was still blasting behind us, and people were looking at us, but neither of us seemed to care.
He looked at me. “What else do you want me to do, Julie?”
“I don’t know.”
“You lied to me.”
“I didn’t mean to.”
“But you still did.” His voice was still quiet. “You could’ve told me, Julie. You could’ve just told me.”
“I couldn’t because I knew you’d react like this.”
His eyes narrowed slightly. “So you thought lying to me was better?”
3/5

Comments
The readers' comments on the novel: Puck Me Harder, Captain (Julie and Logan)
Any updates????...