Login via

Puck Me Harder, Captain (Julie and Logan) novel Chapter 23

23: Lines We Crossed

Her eyes stayed on me, waiting for an answer I wasn’t sure I could give.

55 vouchers

Because honestly, where was I even supposed to start? Yeah, I’m fake dating your brother and we slept together last night.

That was hardly the kind of conversation people had over coffee.

She was definitely never speaking to me again.

I looked at Emma, still waiting for me to say something, when another thought suddenly hit me.

She did say Logan had told her everything.

But… did she truly mean everything?

Every single detail?

My chest tightened.

No.

He wouldn’t.

…Would he?

Surely not.

I tried very hard to believe that as I shifted in my chair and leaned forward. I opened my mouth to answer her, but nothing came out. I swallowed, tried again, and somehow still managed to say absolutely nothing.

“Julie,” Emma sighed.

“I’ll tell you,” I said quickly. “I promise.”

She waited.

I opened my mouth again.

Nothing.

Emma tapped her fingers against the table, not loudly, just enough for me to know her patience was running

out.

I let out a slow breath.

“I’m just… going to say it,” I muttered. “Yes, Logan and I are dating. Well… fake dating.” I hurried to correct myself. “We’re doing it until we both get what we want, and then we’ll go our separate ways. No strings attached. Nobody else knows it’s fake, so… please don’t tell anyone.”

1/5

11:01 Thu, Sep 17

Puck Me Harder, Captain

Emma didn’t look surprised.

“Logan already told me all of that.”

Of course he did.

“What I asked,” she continued, “was whose idea it was.”

“The fake dating?”

:

She gave me a look that made it painfully obvious I already knew the answer to that question.

Right.

55 vouchers

She wasn’t talking about last night. She didn’t know about that. She only knew about the fake dating.

Thank God.

“That was… both of us,” I admitted. “He brought it up first. I said no, then I came back and added my own condition.”

“Julie.”

“I know,” I said before she could continue. “I know how it sounds, but I didn’t know what else to do. I didn’t have anywhere to live, and I couldn’t deal with Hannah by myself anymore. I just… needed something.”

“I understand that,” Emma said. “I really do. But dating Logan-”

“Fake dating,” I corrected automatically.

“Yes,” she said without missing a beat. “Fake dating Logan still comes with a lot of very real consequences.”

I frowned.

“Right now the whole internet thinks you’re Logan Carter’s girlfriend. Every time you’re seen together, that story gets bigger. Even if the two of you eventually go your separate ways, the internet isn’t going to move on just because you do.”

“Is that… a bad thing?” I asked, genuinely confused.

Emma’s shoulders dropped a little.

“You don’t get it, Julie.”

“I know, but whatever it is, I can handle it.”

“For how long?” she asked quietly. “You’re living together. You’re spending every day together. You’re letting the entire world believe you’re in a relationship. That’s not as simple as you’re making it sound.”

“I’ll be fine.”

2/5

11:01 Thu, Sep 17

Puck Me Harder, Captain

1344

55 vouchers

I reached across the table and rested my hand over hers, giving her a faint smile. She returned it just as softly.

I’d spent the entire drive over here convincing myself Emma was going to yell at me.

She didn’t.

She was just worried.

She always was.

“What did Matt say about all this?” she asked.

“He was mostly speechless,” I said, remembering the look on his face when he saw Logan with me. “But Hannah…” I couldn’t help smiling. “You should’ve seen Hannah.”

Emma laughed.

“How good was it?”

“So good,” I said, laughing with her. “She finally shut up. I swear she was trying to say something, but none of the words were coming out anymore.”

“Finally,” Emma said with a smile. “Someone managed to shut her up.”

“I know.” I leaned forward, my smile fading a little. “Which is exactly why I need this, Emma.”

She didn’t answer straight away. Instead, she looked down at the table for a moment before letting out a quiet sigh.

“Look… I know this is helping you right now. I’m really happy about that. It’s just…” She searched for the right words before looking back at me. “I don’t want you getting caught up in something that was never part of the plan.”

I frowned. “What do you mean?”

“You know what I mean.” She lifted a hand with a frustrated sigh. “Logan doesn’t exactly keep things uncomplicated when it comes to women, and now the two of you are living together and pretending to date. I just don’t want either of you crossing a line.”

Crossing a line.

My stomach tightened because I’d already crossed one, and before I could stop myself, my mind wandered right back to last night.

The way he’d lowered me onto the bed.

The way his hand had found the clasp of my bra. The way his mouth had captured my…

Quick check to keep reading. It usually passes on its own.

Reading History

No history.

Comments

The readers' comments on the novel: Puck Me Harder, Captain (Julie and Logan)