Login via

Puck Me Harder, Captain (Julie and Logan) novel Chapter 26

26: Too Familiar

I guess getting your nails done takes three hours.

Or maybe it takes five when you’re Hannah.

55 vouchers

Either way, I’d been setting up this hall for what felt like forever, and she was still nowhere to be found.

Honestly, I should’ve known better.

Expecting Hannah to do exactly what she said she was going to do was like expecting rain not to be wet. At some point, it stopped being her fault and became mine for believing her in the first place.

I let out a sigh and picked up another chair.

What a wonderful way to spend the rest of my day.

I’d already spent the last hours moving chairs, arranging tables, and hanging decorations, yet somehow the hall still looked like it had another three hours’ worth of work left.

I reached for another chair when the hall doors opened.

I looked up.

Matt.

Everything in me paused for just a second.

He smiled the moment he saw me and ran a hand through his hair as he walked over. He was wearing jeans and a light sweater that fit him almost suspiciously well.

Hannah definitely picked that out.

He reached for one of the chairs beside me.

“Need help?”

“Yeah,” I said, trying to sound casual as I turned back to what I was doing.

He picked up another chair and set it beside the others before glancing at me.

“It’s really nice what you’re doing.”

I looked at him, confused.

“Helping Hannah,” he clarified. “She’s lucky to have you. Most people would’ve found an excuse to disappear, but you’re still here.”

Of course I was.

1/5

Puck Me Harder, Captain

I hadn’t exactly been given much of a choice.

“Well…” I let out a small laugh. “I am the maid of honor.”

“Yeah.”

He nodded, but something about the way he said it made me think he meant more than that.

55 vouchers

We fell into a comfortable silence, arranging chairs and straightening the rows until everything faced the same direction.

“So…” Matt said after a while.

I looked over at him.

“You and Logan Carter, huh?”

My stomach tightened.

“I saw the pictures last night.”

Of course he did.

At this point, anyone who hadn’t seen them probably didn’t have internet.

“Yeah,” I replied quietly.

He smiled as he adjusted another chair.

“You know, I didn’t even know you were seeing anyone. Then all of a sudden you’re dating Logan Carter, living with him, and now the entire internet knows about it,”

I tucked a strand of hair behind my ear.

“Thanks… I think?”

“No, I mean it.” He laughed softly. “I’m happy for you. I just would’ve appreciated a little warning before I found out you were dating Logan Carter.”

There it was again.

That laugh.

Somehow it still sounded exactly the same.

I picked up one end of a tablecloth and spread it across the nearest table. Matt grabbed the other end without me asking, helping smooth out the wrinkles.

“By the way,” he said, “please tell me you haven’t told Logan how obsessed I was with him.”

I laughed.

2/5

15:20 Fri, Sep 18

Puck Me Harder, Captain

“Don’t worry,” I said. “I haven’t.”

The relief on his face lasted exactly one second.

“At least… not yet.”

“Oh, Julie.” He groaned. “Do you have any idea how embarrassing that would be?”

“You’ll survive.”

“I won’t.”

“You might even get that autograph you’ve always wanted.”

He pointed a finger at me playfully. “Hey, don’t joke about things like that.”

23

55 vouchers

I laughed again, and for a moment it came so easily that I forgot I wasn’t supposed to be this comfortable around him anymore.

I reached for the box full of tabletop decorations.

“Let me help with that,” Matt said, already reaching for it before I could protest.

His muscles tightened as he lifted it like it weighed nothing, and that was when I noticed the fresh ink peeking out from beneath his sleeve.

“You got a tattoo?” I asked, my voice catching a little more than I wanted it to.

“Yeah.” He smiled. “Hannah thought it’d be cool if we got matching ones.”

He walked back toward me, rolling his sleeve up a little farther so I could get a proper look.

A heart and a moon.

For a second, I just stared.

That had been my idea.

A year ago, I’d mentioned it to Hannah half-jokingly, back when it still felt safe to imagine a future with Matt

in it. We’d laughed about it, talking about how matching tattoos were either incredibly romantic or completely ridiculous. I never imagined she’d remember it.

Or that she’d suggest that to him.

Something in my chest tightened so suddenly it caught me off guard. It wasn’t jealousy.

It wasn’t even anger.

It was the strange, aching realization that a memory I’d always thought belonged to me had somehow become

theirs.

15:20 Fri, Sep 18

Puck Me Harder, Captain

“You like it?” he asked.

I forced myself to look away from the tattoo and back at him.

“Yeah,” I said.

And I meant it.

I hated that I meant it.

$

23

55 vouchers

By the time I looked up, I realized we’d drifted closer without either of us noticing. I could feel the warmth coming off him, and his eyes were doing that thing they always used to do-that quiet, patient way of looking at me that once made me believe I was the only person in the room.

Or maybe I’d only ever imagined that part.

His smile never faded, and my chest tightened all over again because, for one dangerous second, everything felt exactly the way it used to.

Before Hannah.

Before the engagement.

Before I taught myself that wanting him was never going to end well.

I didn’t even realize I was smiling back until I felt it. A real smile. The kind I hadn’t let myself give him in a very long time.

He took a small step closer.

“I think I need to tell you something.”

“What is it?”

Quick check to keep reading. It usually passes on its own.

Reading History

No history.

Comments

The readers' comments on the novel: Puck Me Harder, Captain (Julie and Logan)