59: I Know Her Best
ANNAH’S POV
55 vouchers
Matt was looking at Julie the way he used to before everything changed-before he and I were together, before I poisoned the way he saw her with words I could never take back.
Matt had this thing where he would constantly look at her whenever she wasn’t paying attention. A smile would slowly spread across his face, that soft, annoying smile that used to make me love looking at him.
I hated that it was for her.
For a girl who barely seemed to care what she looked like, even when she was supposed to be dressing up for the man she loved. She wasn’t even trying, and somehow that was the most annoying part. She would just show up as she was, like a fucking rug no one would ever notice, and somehow Matt still thought she looked cute.
He thought her shyness was adorable instead of what I saw as a complete lack of confidence. He looked at her bare face and saw pretty. I looked at it and saw someone who couldn’t even be bothered to put in a little effort to look good for herself.
Everything Julie did was somehow cute to him. Everything about her seemed to scream, ‘this girl is different’
God, that was probably the biggest lie he had ever told himself.
And Julie? Even with all my advice, even when I tried to help her, she still managed to fumble it.
I would tell her, Look pretty today, Julie.
And what would she do?
Put on that rag of an outfit, pull her hair into that sleek bun, swipe on some lip gloss, and somehow walk out thinking she looked cute.
Then she would ask me if Matt noticed her.
Of course he noticed her.
Actually, Matt noticed her a lot more than she ever realized. With him, effort was practically unnecessary. He would probably give a stray cat attention if it walked up to him looking dirty and pathetic.
I could have easily told Julie that he noticed her. I could have told her that he thought she was cute.
But no.
She had already proven to me that she didn’t deserve the truth. And honestly, all those times I had tried to help her were starting to feel like a complete waste of time.
Because the truth was, Julie doesn’t deserve him. I did.
I deserve someone like Matt. Someone who understood me. Someone who cared about the little things. Someone who made being around him feel easy.
14:49 Sat, Sep 19 TO
Puck Me Harder, Captain
So I started making sure she wouldn’t get the chance with him.
Nold her Matt didn’t find her attractive.
I told her he was talking to other girls.
55 vouchers
I told her he was too busy. He didn’t have time for a relationship when hockey already took up so much of
his life.
One lie became another.
And eventually, Julie stopped asking.
She never doubted me. Not once. She never looked at me and said, “Hannah, you’re lying to me.”
She trusted everything I told her until she accepted it as fact. Until she finally understood that, in everything she believed about love and all those little fantasies she had about Matt, he was never going to be part of any of them.
Matt and Julie were never going to happen.
At least, that was what I thought.
Until the day Matt looked at me and said, “I think I’m in love with Julie.”
Thank God Julie wasn’t home to hear that.
And thank God Matt was just as easy to convince as she was.
I told him I’d talk to her. I’d find out if she felt the same way. And I did. Every time Julie said something, I took it apart for him and gave it back in a way that made sense to me.
She didn’t mean that.
She isn’t interested in you, Matt.
She only sees you as a friend.
Eventually, he started believing it too.
Matt stopped pursuing her. He stopped looking for reasons to be around her and eventually chose me instead.
I helped him get over her.
And somewhere along the way, I became the person he loved.
After that, Matt never looked at Julie twice. He stopped staring at her when she wasn’t looking. He stopped talking to her in that way he used to, like there was always something more he wanted to say but never did.
Until tonight.
He was doing it again.
14:49 Sat, Sep 19
Puck Me Harder, Captain
Looking at her when she didn’t notice.
55 vouchers
And Julie was walking around the room like she belonged there. Like the whole night had somehow been arranged for her. People kept approaching her, talking to her, smiling at her, and she seemed completely comfortable with all of it.
It was almost irritating to watch.
My hands curled into fists beneath the table, but I forced myself to relax. There were cameras everywhere and I wasn’t about to let one catch me sitting there looking miserable.
But then I looked at Julie again.
At her with Logan.
That confidence hadn’t been there before. Neither had that smile. I used to know when Julie was pretending to be happy. I knew the difference between the real thing and the polite little smile she gave people because she didn’t know what else to do.
But this one looked real.
Too real.
And I couldn’t understand it.
How was someone like Julie with someone like Logan?

Comments
The readers' comments on the novel: Puck Me Harder, Captain (Julie and Logan)
Any updates????...