(Clarice)
Natasha's standing in the doorway, staring at me like I'm a problem that got delivered to the wrong address.
I am exactly the problem she thinks I am, but I’m at the right address.
I brought wine because Julian said not to show up empty-handed, and now I'm standing here holding a bottle neither of us is ever going to open.
Like an idiot.
Like a girl on a first date with her own daughter.
"Julian."
Natasha doesn't look at him.
She doesn't look away from me as she speaks.
"You have thirty seconds to explain why she's on my porch."
"I was getting to that," Julian says. "She wasn't supposed to get out of the car."
The last is said with a stern glance in my direction.
"I got tired of waiting," I say.
First words out of my mouth, and that's what I lead with.
Brilliant.
I left her for more than twenty years and waiting in the car for an hour is more than I want to put up with.
This is not going to go well.
Natasha's jaw sets and I can see the stubborn tilt to it.
She was like this even as a child.
Sweet as condensed milk and stubborn as a mule.
She steps back from the door.
I know this is not an invitation but a logistics decision.
She’s been in the news far too often this past year. Who knows when someone on the street notices our little tableau and decides to record it, or snap a few pictures.
So I’m allowed in because she doesn't want a story written about her tonight.
"Inside. Both of you.”
I follow her in like I haven't spent years rehearsing every version of this hallway in my head, none of which involved a bottle of wine nobody wants.
And then I see her.
On the rug, pulling herself up with the help of the coffee table.
Lily.
My granddaughter.
The one James sends me three lines about every few weeks.
I’ve built an entire person from those secondhand sentences, but the reality is so much more amazing than the phantom I created.
She's grown so much since I last saw her at the hospital.
It’s almost impossible to believe she was so sick just a few months ago.
She’s so beautiful.
I take one step toward the rug.
"Don't you dare."
Natasha's voice doesn't rise. It doesn't need to.
She walks over and scoops Lily into her arms, like she’s afraid I may ignore her wishes and reach for her daughter.
I stop where I am, three feet short of my grandchild, wine bottle still in my hand like a hostage I forgot to release.
Lily looks over at the new shape in the doorway.
Weighs it for half a second, then turns and grabs two fistfuls of Natasha's sweater, burying half her face against her mother's chest.
How it reminds her of what’s really important.
Natasha doesn't look away from me once.
"That's still not a reason to be in my house tonight. Without an invitation."
"No," I say. "It's not. But it’s the only truth I've got. The part that might actually earn anything, I haven't figured out how to say yet."
"Go home, Clarice. I have a lot going on. There’s no space in my life for this right now."
Not cruel. Just final.
There’s nothing unambiguous about her answer.
I came braced for shouting.
I could've survived that.
Her quiet distance is much harder to overcome.
I leave the wine on the counter. Taking it back out feels like removing evidence.
"Thank you for the thirty seconds," I say, and mean it more than anything I've said in months.
Julian touches my elbow, steering me toward the door before I do something worse, like cry in front of the granddaughter I'm not allowed to hold yet.
I get one more look at her over my shoulder on the way out. Still gripping the sweater. Still watching me like I might be dangerous.
Outside, Julian opens the car door like that fixes anything.
"I'm sorry," he says, the regret in his voice genuine.
He’s become a different man since Taylor’s death. Less peacock, more sincere.
The events of the last hour prove that he’s no wiser than he ever was though.
"I thought if I just got you both in a room-"
"You thought wrong. It’s okay."

Comments
The readers' comments on the novel: She Was Never Just the Billionaire’s Wife (Natasha and Chase)