The Billionaire Heir Fell for the Wrong Girl
Chapter 269 Gifts
$5 vouchers
Jeremiah still hadn’t given Hathaway her phone back. After his shower that night, he easily unlocked it and slid into the home screen.
He opened the photo album and scrolled through. There were plenty of scenic shots from different places, but most were everyday photos of the twins. The sweet, soft smiles on Hathaway’s face in the pictures with the twins stirred something complicated in Jeremiah’s heart.
Jeremiah thought, ‘She hasn’t smiled at me like that in years.
He swallowed the sour feeling in his chest, closed the photo album, and opened Whatsapp. A friend request popped up in the message bar.
Someone with the nickname “Lila” was spamming her with requests, same profile picture every time. Judging by the frequency, it was probably some guy.
A chill flashed in Jeremiah’s eyes. Without a second thought, he accepted the friend request.
Messages started flooding in almost instantly:
[Sweetie, you finally added me! I’m so happy!]
[The internet’s blowing up with rumors. I heard Jeremiah kept you locked up in the mountains for a month. Can you talk about it?]
[Jeremiah’s so hot, sweetie. You must’ve totally fallen for him, right?]
Jeremiah paused, thinking to himself, ‘Not sure if I buy this.’ He tapped the screen and replied with a single, indifferent word: [Yeah.]
That was like poking a hornet’s nest.
The other side instantly blew up, sending a flood of messages, each one practically buzzing with excitement:
[Oh my god! It’s mutual! My ship is actually sailing!]
[So after spending a whole month together up in the mountains, you two really got closer, didn’t you?]
[Sweetie, give me all the juicy details!]
Jeremiah finally got why Hathaway never added this person, no wonder. He was ready to hit delete and kick them out of her contacts.
But before he could, the other person sent over a throwback photo. Jeremiah in his high school uniform, standing next to a younger, delicate Hathaway who had just started middle school.
Her big eyes were shining with a shy smile as she looked at him, her face still soft and naive, a little awkward and bashful. It was obvious at a glance. She totally had a crush on him back then.
1/4
15:31 Sat, Sep 19
The Billionaire Heir Fell for the Wrong Girl
58 vouch
39
Jeremiah’s finger gently traced the outline of her eyes and brows in the photo, and his cold, hard expression softened without him even realizing it.
She used to smile at him like that so often, but he always overlooked it back then.
Regret flooded his heart, making it hard for him to breathe.
Looks like this “Lila” is actually an ally. Jeremiah went ahead and typed: [Got any more photos?]
The reply popped up almost instantly: [I’ve got loads! Want them all, Hattie?]
Jeremiah stared at the screen and replied without hesitation: [Yeah, I want them.]
He paused for a second, then added: [Name your price, I’ll buy them.]
The screen went quiet for a couple of seconds, then Lila Montgomery’s message popped up: [Wait, you’re not Hattie?]
Half an hour later, Jeremiah sat alone in the coffee house, quietly waiting.
Lila Montgomery pushed open the wooden door, walked over with a spring in her step, and sat down across from him. Her eyes were dazzling with excitement as she called out, “Jeremiah.”
Jeremiah didn’t bother with small talk. He slid a black card across the table, his tone cold and to the point. “Money for photos, hand them over.”
Lila promptly passed over the old digital camera she’d been carrying in her arms.
Jeremiah took the camera and switched it on. The screen came to life, showing an album stuffed with old photos. Every single shot from his high school days, untouched by time, each memory preserved perfectly after all these years.
There was a shot of Hathaway with her hair pulled up in a high ponytail, a sheen of sweat on her brow as she beamed at the camera. Next to her, the teenage Jeremiah was watching her from the side, his eyes brimming with a tenderness he couldn’t hide.
Another photo showed them on the beach. Jeremiah reclining in a beach chair, while Hathaway leaned in so close their breaths nearly mingled, faces just inches apart.
There was also a close–up of Hathaway standing quietly at his side, both of them gazing at the sunset painting the sky in a riot of colors.
Jeremiah’s eyes stayed glued to the screen, his usual hard expression finally relaxing as a rush of emotions he couldn’t even name surged up inside him.
He’d almost forgotten these fragments of his youth, those clumsy first crushes, the silent days spent side by side, all those bittersweet memories perfectly sealed away in these photos.
Every picture felt like a blade, slicing right through the armor of denial he’d built around himself for so many
years.
2/4
15:31 Sat, Sep 19
The Billionaire Heir Fell for the Wrong Girl
39
BB Vouchers
Jeremiah thought to himself, ‘How clueless was I back then? Just because my friends spread rumors about the Whitmore family chasing after power and wealth, I let it cloud my judgment without a second thought.
‘I kept freezing Hathaway out, hurting her over and over, even though she was always devoted to me, her whole world revolving around me.’
“It’s so obvious in every single photo. Back then, Hattie was all about you, you were the only one she cared about,” Lila said softly.
Jeremiah’s Adam’s apple bobbed as he pressed his fingertips to the cool screen, his voice barely above a whisper. “Yeah.”
Lila sighed softly. “Photos don’t lie, you know. You’re the one who pushed away the girl who adored you with everything she had.”
Jeremiah kept his eyes glued to the photos, not saying a word. She used to love him with everything she had, never holding anything back. And he was the one who crushed that love, the one who let her down so badly.
“Mr. Blackwood? Are you alright?” Lila’s voice pulled him back to reality.
For a moment, Jeremiah blinked, Lila’s voice snapping him out of his daze and dragging him back to the
present.
He finally looked away, a complicated, wistful look flickering in his eyes. “Sorry,” he said quietly, “it’s just feels like fate just blindsided me.”
He gripped the camera tighter, a barely–there, bittersweet smile flickering at his lips. “Thank you. I mean it. These really mean a lot to me.”
He tucked the old camera away with care and left, taking it with him.
The next day was Sunday. Jeremiah went all out, showing up at the Whitmore family’s house with his car packed to the brim with expensive gifts.
The coffee table in the living room was buried under gift boxes, and he even threw in a luxury, top–spec lavender sports car for good measure. But from the moment he walked in to when he finally sat down, there was still no sign of Hathaway anywhere.
Sylvia Whitmore sat on the couch, and when Jeremiah walked in, she didn’t even bother to hide her coldness. Her expression was frosty, making it clear she wasn’t about to be polite.
Even though Edmund Blackwood had spent all of yesterday trying every trick in the book, pulling at her heartstrings, laying out all the reasons, and singing Jeremiah’s praises. Sylvia still wasn’t buying it.
She might’ve wavered a bit, but honestly, she just couldn’t stand Jeremiah’s pushy, controlling ways. No matter what, she still had a chip on her shoulder about him.
Celeste Rivers was the one welcoming everyone and keeping the guests company.
3/4
15:31 Sat, Sep 19
The Billionaire Heir Fell for the Wrong Girl
39
85 vouchers
Jeremiah had no interest in dealing with the chilly atmosphere in the living room. In a calm, almost indifferent tone, he said, “Mrs. Whitmore, I’m going to return Hattie’s phone.”
Jeremiah kept a tight grip on the phone he’d been holding onto, but Sylvia cut him off, her tone cool and firm: “No need. Give it to me. I’ll make sure she gets it.”
He reached out to hand it over, and Sylvia immediately snatched it from his grasp.
Just then, Jeremiah’s phone started ringing. He stepped off to the side, spoke in a low voice for a moment, and then turned back to the living room, still on the call. “It’s Grandpa. He wants Hattie to talk to him.”
Guess Sylvia only let it slide this time because it was Edmund asking.
Jeremiah headed upstairs and pushed open the bedroom door. The moment his eyes landed on Hathaway’s face, completely drained of color, his brows furrowed tight, and his voice dropped, thick with concern. “Why do you look so pale?”
Jeremiah gently placed the phone by Hathaway’s side and softly reminded her, “It’s Grandpa calling.”
Hathaway hesitated for a moment, then picked up the phone. Edmund’s gentle voice came through clearly: “Hathaway?”
“Mr. Blackwood,” Hathaway replied softly.
“Hathaway, when are you going to come visit me at the Blackwood house? All I want is for you and Jeremiah to settle down together and live a happy, peaceful life,” Edmund said, his voice warm and full of hope.
4/4

Comments
The readers' comments on the novel: The Billionaire Heir Fell for the Wrong Girl (Hathaway Whitmore)
Pls update...