Abigail
"Is it your secret stash of human bones?" I teased as he led me deeper into the cave, away from the waterfall’s roaring sound. "A dungeon? A sex dungeon? Please say it’s a sex dungeon."
"Christ," Finnegan groaned, his entire body shaking with laughter before he tugged me into a narrow passage. "You’re insatiable today."
"I feel like I could fuck you three times a day and still want more. Is this normal? Should I be worried?" I rambled, clinging to him tighter as the darkness deepened, pressing my breasts against his arm.
"Baby," he rasped, his voice dropping an octave, "if you keep talking like that, I’m going to take you against this wall before we even get to the surprise."
"Promises, promises," I whispered, my hand sliding down to squeeze his ass through the wet swim trunks.
It got so dark for a while that I couldn’t see my own hand in front of my face.
"Okay, seriously, I’m getting kind of nervous," I rambled, clinging to him tighter. "Is this some kind of kink?"
"Christ," he groaned, his entire body shaking with laughter, before he tugged me into an open space and rasped, "Look up,"
I did, and a gasp fell from my lips. The ceiling of the cave was alive with light.
Thousands of tiny blue lights, glowing softly and pulsing like stars that had fallen from the sky and gotten trapped in the cave. They cast the entire chamber in an ethereal, underwater blue and silver glow.
"Bioluminescent algae," Finnegan said softly. "They only grow in places like this. I found this cave years ago, when I first bought the island."
I stared up at the lights, my breath catching in my throat. "It’s beautiful,"
"Yeah," he smiled, wrapping his arms around me, pulling me closer to his chest. "Do you know what makes them even more beautiful?"
"What?"
"They’re the color of your eyes,"
And that had me melting into a heap of feelings.
"You have the most gorgeous set of blue eyes I have ever seen. And just like this cave is the sanctuary where these algae bloom, I want to be your sanctuary, Abigail. I want you to trust me, to want me, to... to love me, and I will. I will give you the world and more."
My eyelids fluttered rapidly as tears stung my eyes. "I already do. You know I already do,"
His lips brushed over mine softly, his scent filling my senses.
I hugged him tighter to myself. "I don’t need the world, I already have you."
"Do you think the algae will be offended if you fuck me now?"
I cupped his cock through the thin swim trunks, feeling how hard and hot he already was. My fingers stroked him slowly, squeezing the thick length as I continued lavishing attention on his chest.
"Poor baby," I purred, my voice husky. "All these years and no one ever played with these pretty nipples? Such a shame."
He cursed under his breath, hips jerking into my hand. His knuckles whitened where he gripped the cave wall, every muscle in his torso rippling and tightening as he fought not to take control.
The restraint only made me wetter. I loved pushing my dominant man to the edge like this.
"Abigail," he warned, his voice strained. "If you keep teasing me, I’m going to lose my fucking mind."
I slid lower, kissing and licking down the deep grooves of his abs, tracing every ridge with my tongue.
When I reached his navel, I dipped my tongue inside teasingly, swirling it while my hand kept stroking his cock through the fabric. He was throbbing already, leaking precum, the head of his cock pushing insistently against the waistband.
I hooked my fingers into his trunks and tugged them down just enough to peek inside. His cock sprang forward, thick, veined, and flushed dark with need, the tip glistening with precum.
I grinned up at him, eyes sparkling in the blue glow of the algae. Poor things were getting the show of the century. "Is this all for me?"
Finnegan’s chest heaved, his gaze burning down at me with barely leashed hunger that made arousal pool hot and heavy between my thighs. I pressed them together, feeling my pussy throb. "Every fucking inch, baby. Now be a good girl and—"
I cut him off by dragging my tongue slowly up the underside of his big cock.

Comments
The readers' comments on the novel: The Stranger Behind My Orgasm