He never told her how he felt, so she just played dumb and pretended she didn’t know. Marrying Jordan, if she was honest, had a little bit to do with wanting to get back at Ethan.
Now look at her. Jordan had cheated and thrown everything away, and Ethan didn’t want her, either.
“Natalie, don’t say things you’ll regret later. I get it, what Jordan did really hurt you, but this isn’t the time to lose control. You need to calm down and figure out what you actually want to do about your marriage.”
“Are you thinking about divorce, or do you want to try to work things out? If you want a divorce, how are you going to split everything? If you need help, I can get you the best lawyer and make sure you’re taken care of.”
“But about you asking me to marry you… I can’t do that. It doesn’t matter how I feel about Isabella. All I know is, she’s the only one I want to marry, and she’s the one I want to spend my life with.”
“I don’t even question whether it’s love anymore. I just go with what feels right.”
He was just being honest with himself.
“The past is over. No matter how much we regret it, we can’t turn back time. If I could, I’d do things differently. I never should have used Isabella. I should have treated her with my whole heart.”
“I should have tried to build a good life with her. I wouldn’t have been such an idiot, treating you better than my own wife. My grandma was right when she yelled at me. I ignored my own wife and looked after someone else’s.”
“I was the one who pushed my wife toward Harold. I can’t blame Harold for wanting to take her from me.”
“Natalie, stop grabbing me. Jordan cheating is on him. Don’t make the same mistake. If Jordan saw how you just acted, wouldn’t he think you were the one cheating?”
That made Natalie think of what Jordan had said to his secretary.
He claimed that after he got drunk that night, she went out in the middle of the night to find Ethan.
How did Jordan know?
Did he know she had actually tried to throw herself at Ethan that night?
Ethan walked over and unlocked the office door.
He cracked it open and saw his cousin still standing there. He must have been listening at the door. When Ethan opened it, Jeremy looked a little embarrassed and managed a weak smile.
Ethan just opened the door all the way. “Come in and sit down,” he said. “Natalie’s having a hard time. Maybe you can help her.”
Jeremy’s eyes went wide. He pointed at himself. “Me? Help her?”
He glanced at Natalie, who was still crying and tearing through tissues, clearly not over it.
Then he looked at Ethan, who didn’t look even a little bit upset anymore. Seeing that, Jeremy actually felt relieved. Ethan had finally snapped out of it. Natalie couldn’t play him anymore.
“Ethan,” Jeremy said quietly, “Natalie’s not my girlfriend. Be careful, okay? I mean, I’m single, but if people start talking, it could mess up my chances to get married someday.”

Comments
The readers' comments on the novel: After I Stopped Loving Him (Isabella and Ethan)
Author, please get your characters names right. You always messing them up!...
I wish Harold will win Isabella's heart. I was so sad when Isabela was taken for granted coldly and cruelly by her supposed to be husband, and trapped,mocked and humiliated non stop by Natalie. This was so cruel, both don't deserve Isabela' forgiveness I wish for a happy ending between Isabela and Harold, he has the right to be happy after the long wait....
Frankly, the story initially was going quite good and the pacing was just right. unfortunately after Ethan got the dream of his past life, the story has been going in circles. Ethan's spouting the same nonsense every time he sees Isabella, they both have same conversations over and over. The authors monologue too has been the same for almost 400 chapters. Irrespective of which character the writing the just a repetition of what someone had gone through in the past and what made a certain character feel the emotions. York got introduced in 800 chapters yet nothing significant happened till date. Isabella is soft with Harold and kind of disgusted with Ethan, yet it is not entirely clear with whom she might end up. If she stays single i am fine with it but the story is clearly about Isabella and Ethan so almost 1000 chapters without seeing any progress in their relationship is frustrating. Except for being blindly in love and few aggressive instances with Isabella, Ethan actually isnt a bad person so i am fine if he can win her back. Even though Harold is coming off as a good second lead, i am somehow unable to warm upto him. Even the bad people in the story are not really facing any real consequences. I hate Jackson for his hypocrisy. I hate Jordan and Natalie for their self-righteouness and selfishness. I also hate Deborah, except when she is handing it out to Natalie. I am almost on the verge of dropping this story....
Why are they acting like kids 🤣😭...
Ethan is actually not that bad if we take out his blind love for Natalie...