Caleb’s POV
Justice sounds nothing like I imagined.
The foreman's voice is steady and unremarkable, the kind you'd hear reading a grocery list or calling names at a doctor's office.
He doesn't pause for dramatic effect. He doesn't look at Lucas or the gallery or the women sitting three rows behind me who lived through the worst nights of their lives so they could be here.
He just reads.
"On count one of sexual assault in the first degree, we find the defendant guilty."
The courtroom holds its breath.
"On count two of sexual assault in the first degree, we find the defendant guilty."
Beside me, Rachel makes a sound that doesn't have a name — half gasp, half sob, the kind of noise that gets ripped from your chest when the thing you've been bracing for actually happens and your body doesn't know whether to collapse or celebrate.
"On count three — guilty."
The word lands four more times. Each count, each verdict strips another layer from the polished fiction that has protected Lucas Bennett his entire life.
Patricia Bennett's knees buckle first. She folds into Richard like a building losing its foundation, her manicured fingers clawing at his suit jacket while a sound tears from her throat that I'll remember for years.
Richard catches her with the mechanical precision of a man who has been expecting this collapse, his jaw set, his eyes fixed on the wall behind the judge's bench because looking at his son would require acknowledging what his son has done.
Lucas doesn't move.
He stands at the defense table with his hands at his sides, and his face is so blank it looks like someone hit a reset button behind his eyes.
No rage. No tears. No defiance. Just the vacant shock of a man who spent his entire existence believing the rules were written for other people, and is only now discovering that they apply to him too.
"Oh my God," Rachel breathes, pressing both hands over her mouth. Tears stream between her fingers. "Oh my God, it's real. Tell me it's real."
"It's real," I tell her, and my own voice sounds distant, like it's coming from the far end of a long corridor. "It's done, Rach."
Jessica sits two rows ahead of us, gripping the bench in front of her with knuckles bleached white against the wood. Her shoulders shake, but she doesn't make a sound.
Then Serena's fingers thread through mine.
She grips so hard I feel her nails break skin, crescent moons digging into the flesh between my knuckles.
The sting registers somewhere far away, like pain happening to someone else's body.
"Caleb." Her voice splinters on my name.
"I know." I tighten my hand around hers. "I know."
The judge is speaking — remanding Lucas into custody, setting a sentencing date — but the words wash over me like white noise.
All I can see is Lucas being guided away by two officers who flank him with practiced indifference.
His attorney reaches for his arm and Lucas flinches, the first sign of life since the verdict, and for one disorienting second his eyes sweep the gallery and find mine.
I wait for the satisfaction to hit. The triumph. The righteous, roaring vindication I've been carrying in my chest since Halloween night, since I walked into that bedroom and found him on top of her.
The officers steer him through a side door, and it closes with a click that sounds nothing like closure.
The war took something from you that winning can't return.
VERIFYCAPTCHA_LABEL
Comments
The readers' comments on the novel: Hate Me Like You Love Me (Serena and Caleb)