Serena’s POV
The longest conversations in a family never happen at the dinner table — they happen in the silence between people who are terrified of saying the wrong thing.
We sit in the living room like opposing counsel. William and Catherine on one couch, shoulders nearly touching, a united front held together by shared dread.
Caleb and I on the other, close enough that the heat from his body radiates through my sleeve. Neither of us reaches for the other's hand. Not yet. Not until we know what this room is about to become.
Catherine's fingers twist the edge of a throw pillow, and my father stares at a fixed point on the carpet as though he's reading from a script only he can see.
He clears his throat.
"I've spent the last several days trying to find the right way to say this." William's voice is low and deliberate, each word placed with the precision of a man who's rehearsed this speech in the mirror, in the shower, in the car.
"I kept looking for language that would make it easier. Something that would let us all walk out of this room without anyone bleeding."
He lifts his gaze and looks directly at me first, then at Caleb.
"But there's no version of this that's comfortable, so I'm going to say it plainly." He draws a breath that seems to take everything he has. "My daughter is in a romantic relationship with my wife's son."
The words land in the room with the weight of a verdict. No one flinches. We've all known this was coming — the naming of the thing we've danced around for weeks — but hearing it spoken aloud in my father's steady baritone makes it irreversible.
You can pretend a truth doesn't exist as long as nobody says it out loud.
"I'm not going to call it wrong." William holds up a hand as though anticipating an objection that hasn't come. "And I'm not going to call it right. What I will call it is complicated. Because that's what it is. It is profoundly, deeply complicated, and pretending otherwise helps no one."
Caleb shifts beside me, his jaw tight, his breathing measured. I can feel the tension coiled through his body — the effort it takes him to sit still and let someone else control the narrative.
Catherine leans forward. Her eyes are red-rimmed, and I realize she's been crying before we even sat down.
She's wearing the soft gray cardigan she always reaches for on days when she needs armor that doesn't look like armor.
"When I walked into that bedroom and saw you two together, it was one of the most shocking moments of my life." Her voice wavers but doesn't break. "I need you both to understand that my reaction wasn't performance. It was genuine shock, and I'm not going to apologize for it."
She pauses, pressing her lips together until the trembling stops.
"But I've had time to sit with it. To think about what I actually saw, not just what I assumed I was seeing." Catherine looks at Caleb, then at me, and her expression shifts into something raw and unguarded.
"What I saw was two people who would rather burn down every comfortable thing in their lives than let go of each other. And I recognized it, because I've lived it."
"When I left Simon, I had nothing. A son with bruises I couldn't explain to pediatricians and a suitcase full of clothes that smelled like a house I never wanted to step foot in again."
A broken child. Beside me, Caleb's breathing catches so slightly that only I notice.
VERIFYCAPTCHA_LABEL
Comments
The readers' comments on the novel: Hate Me Like You Love Me (Serena and Caleb)