72: The Pieces Fit
OGAN POV
I rubbed a hand over my face as I watched Julie leave.
55 vouchers
Seeing her cry was bad enough. Seeing her pull away from me like she couldn’t stand having me near her was worse. I couldn’t blame her. Whatever she thought she’d seen, I had no way of explaining it yet.
When her car disappeared down the road, I headed back inside. Going after her while she was that upset wouldn’t help.
Hannah’s eyes found me the second I walked into the living room. She looked at me the same way everyone else did, like they were all trying to figure out whether I had actually slept with Alia.
I hadn’t.
That wasn’t even a question.
The last thing I clearly remembered was dancing. After that, everything went blank, and then I woke up with Alia beside me.
I hadn’t been drinking, so none of it made sense. Even if I had been drunk, I would have known if something had happened between us. I knew my own body well enough to know that much.
When I woke up, I felt someone beside me and assumed it was Julie. I smiled and pulled her closer without thinking. I would have kissed her forehead if I hadn’t opened my eyes and realized it was Alia.
I still didn’t know how Alia had ended up in my bed, but I didn’t have time to figure it out now.
I went back into the room for my shirt and phone. Alia was still sitting on the bed, watching me as though she expected me to say something.
I didn’t.
My shirt was folded neatly on the couch.
I picked it up and stared at it for a second.
That alone told me something. If I’d slept with Alia, why would I have taken the time to fold my shirt and leave it there?
I put it on, grabbed my phone, then looked around for my shoes.
They were gone,
“Are you leaving?”
I ignored Alia and kept looking,
Finding my shoes was more important than whatever conversation she thought we were about to have.
She didn’t seem to understand that.
1/4
SAT
19
Οι
T
|||
O
Howread
Puck Me Harder, Captain
“Good thing Julie left, right?”
55 vouchers
That made me pause, but I still didn’t give her a reaction. Find the shoes, leave, deal with everything else later. Alia wasn’t worth my attention right now.
“Did you see her face?” Alia said with a small scoff.
That made me look at her.
“It was hilarious,” she added with a quiet laugh.
“Hilarious?” My voice came out colder than I intended. “You thought that was fucking hilarious?”
“You don’t?”
“She was crying, Alia.”
I shook my head, trying to understand how she could stand there and call it funny. Julie had looked at me like she didn’t even recognize me, and when I tried to get close, she told me not to touch her.
How the fuck was that hilarious?
“This whole thing…” I dragged a hand over my face. “I fucking broke her.”
The image came back again-the tears in her eyes, the way she wouldn’t look at me, the way she kept stepping away whenever I moved closer.
“So what? She cried. It doesn’t matter.”
“It matters to me.”
The words came out before I could stop them.
“I care that she cried. I care that I made her cry. Do you have any idea how hurt she is right now?”
“Jesus Christ, Logan.”
Alia got out of the bed, and I immediately looked away. She was still wearing lingerie, and I had no interest in giving her the wrong idea.
“You sound like a fucking loser,” she said. “What has she done to you?”
Nothing.
She hadn’t done anything to me.
That was the problem. I was the one who had hurt her, and I needed to fix it.
Alia sighed and stepped closer, moving toward me.
“You know, I can fix you,” she said. “Forget about her and focus on me. Like last night.”
I stepped back immediately.
2/4
SAT
19
O
3
O T
O
14:53 Sat, Sep 19
Puck Me Harder, Captain
“Nothing happened last night, Alia.”
She laughed softly, like I’d said something amusing.
55 vouchers
“You know, I know a lot of things about you, Logan, but I didn’t expect you to sleep with a girl and then pretend it didn’t happen.”
I scoffed. “I don’t have time for this nonsense.”
“Logan, honey. Don’t say that. Just lie back down and I’ll finish what we started.”
My hands curled into fists as I opened my mouth to answer, but I stopped myself. I wasn’t about to make matters worse. I took a breath before looking at her.
“Look, Alia, I don’t tolerate lies, and the only reason you’re still standing there telling me one is because you’re a woman. Otherwise…”
I let the rest of the sentence hang.
Her smile disappeared.
I let out a slow breath. “Nothing happened last night. And when I prove that, you’re going to regret making me deal with this.”
I turned away from her and went back to looking for my shoes, checking beside the bed and around the couch before finally losing my patience.
“Fuck. Where the fuck are my shoes?”
Alia pointed behind the door, where they were sitting neatly beside each other.
I stared at them for a moment. That was another thing that didn’t make sense. If something had happened between us, I couldn’t imagine taking the time to leave my shoes sitting there so neatly.
I grabbed them, put them on, picked up my keys, and walked out.
Hannah was in the living room, looking far too pleased with herself.

Comments
The readers' comments on the novel: Puck Me Harder, Captain (Julie and Logan)
Any updates????...