73: They Still Choose Her
ANNAH’S POV
55 vouchers
“You should have seen the look on her face. Oh, it was so worth it.” I laughed so hard my stomach started to hurt. “She literally walked into the room, saw you two together, and just started tearing up.”
Alia laughed with me from the couch, taking another sip of her champagne.
We were back at my apartment, Alia had come with me, and now we were celebrating with champagne and music because, honestly, we had every reason to.
“Now she knows Logan doesn’t belong to her,” Alia said.
“Oh, clearly she does.” I couldn’t stop smiling.
“Next time I see Julie, she’s going to be exactly the way she was before. Weak, broken, and alone.” I leaned back, already enjoying the thought. “And I’ll be the one to help her get back up. Just like old times, except this time, she won’t have anyone else to run to.”
Alia sighed. “That would have been amazing if I could actually get Logan to look at me again. I tried, but he was too busy worrying about Julie. He kept saying she was crying. Like, who gives a fuck that she cried?”
“Give it two days. He’ll come around.” I took another sip of champagne. “Julie isn’t exactly good at letting things go, and once Logan realizes she’s not going to move past this, he’ll get tired of dealing with her.”
That was the whole point. Julie was the one I needed to break.
If things were the other way around, Logan might have believed Julie if she told him nothing happened. But Julie? She was different. She’d seen enough to start questioning him, and once she started doubting herself, I knew exactly where she’d end up.
“Really? Guys, really?”
Fina walked into the living room looking furious.
“Relax. I got more champagne for everyone.”
“This isn’t about some fucking champagne,” Becca said. “We just saw the news. I can’t believe you guys actually did that.”
“The plan was to make Julie feel like she didn’t belong, not drag Logan and the media into it too,” Fina added.
I scoffed. “What’s the big deal?”
“The big deal is that you took it too far,” Courtney said. “What happens when Logan finds out the truth? Or worse, when he finds out we were involved and that we all lied about him to Julie?”
“Relax. He’s not going to find out.”
“Look, I know Logan Carter well enough to know he’s going to fight back sooner or later. So when he comes after you, keep our fucking names out of it.”
14:53 Sat, Sep 19 TO.
Puck Me Harder, Captain
55 vouchers
She turned to leave, Fina and Becca following behind her, both of them giving me the same annoyed look as they walked away.
I rolled my eyes. “Oh, please. What a pussy.”
Alia looked less amused.
“What if he does find out? He told me he would.”
“How is he going to find out when there’s no evidence?” I asked, almost laughing. “He’s not going to. I’ make sure of that.”
She nodded and took another sip of her champagne, but she was drinking it slowly now. She was still
worried.
I wasn’t.
Logan wasn’t going to find out.
I opened my mouth to speak, but stopped when Matt walked in. His eyes landed on Alia first, and then on me. I noticed the change in his expression immediately.
“Can I please have some privacy with my fiancée?” he asked politely.
That was Matt. Even when he was upset, he never seemed capable of being rude.
“Oh, yeah. Sure.”
Alia got up and walked out of the room.
Matt waited until she was gone before looking at me. “What is she doing here?”
“She came to hang out,” I said, like it was nothing. To me, it wasn’t. Matt clearly didn’t see it that way.
He let out a quiet sigh. “I feel bad for Julie.”
“We all do.” I moved closer and rested a hand on his shoulder. “What happened was really sad, Matt. I’m sorry for her, but if we’re being honest…”
I looked away when I felt a smile trying to form.
“Julie should have seen it coming.”
I turned back to him, putting on a sympathetic look. “I’m not trying to be mean, but honestly, wasn’t it obvious? Logan has never exactly been known for being committed.”
“I know that and I told her about it, but she assured me he was good to her.”
I paused.
He told her?
When had that happened?
14:53 Sat, Sep 19
Puck Me Harder, Captain
55 vouchers
“Yeah.” I sighed and looked away again. “But at least now we know who Logan really is, and Julie just has to deal with it.”
Mat nodded, but he stayed quiet for a moment. Then he looked at me.
“I just don’t understand why anyonic would do something like that. Julie is an amazing person. She’s kind, she’s sweet, she’s calm, and she’s really lovely.”
He said it almost to himself, and I knew that look. I hadn’t seen it on his face in a year, but I knew exactly what it meant.
It was the same look he used to get whenever he talked about Julie. Back when he loved her.
“How can someone cheat on a woman like that?” he asked quietly.
My stomach tightened, but I kept my smile.
“Maybe you don’t know everything that happened,” I said. “Maybe Julie did something that pushed him to it. Sometimes people cheat because of what’s going on in their relationship.”

Comments
The readers' comments on the novel: Puck Me Harder, Captain (Julie and Logan)
Any updates????...