75: Not Just Fake
55
E55 vouchers
stayed like that for a while before I finally pulled away and wiped the rest of my tears.
“Now can we please eat the bagel? I’m really hungry,” Matt said, his voice taking on a slightly childish tone.
That made me smile a little. “Yeah.”
I reached for mine and took a small bite, and the taste immediately caught my attention.
“Wait,” I said, turning to face Matt. “Did you get this from Jeff’s Bagel Run?”
They were the only ones who made them this good.
“I had to bring you the best in town,”
“But that’s like a thirty-minute drive.”
“And it’s worth it.” He lifted his bagel for me to see. “It’s so good.”
“Yeah.” I took another small bite.
For a while, we just ate in comfortable silence, and it was almost easy to forget everything that had happened.
Then I heard keys turning in the lock. My hand clutched the bagel tighter before I could stop it.
I knew who it was before the door even opened.
“Logan’s home,” I said quietly, more to myself than to Matt.
My heart started beating faster, and suddenly I wasn’t sure I was ready to see him. Not after this morning. Not when I still couldn’t decide whether I was angry with him, hurt by him, or simply too embarrassed to
look at him.
Matt looked at me. “You want me to ask him to give you some space?”
“I don’t know.”
I said it honestly because I really didn’t know what I wanted him to do. This was Logan’s house, after all. I couldn’t exactly ask him to leave just because I didn’t know how to face him right now.
Before Matt could say anything else, I heard Logan’s footsteps coming across the floor.
My stomach twisted.
Maybe asking him for some space wouldn’t be such a bad idea after all. I don’t think I can face him yet.
Logan walked into the room looking exhausted, his hair damp and his shirt sticking slightly to his skin as if he had gone to the gym before coming home.
His eyes landed on Matt first, and his jaw tightened before he looked at me.
14:54 Sat, Sep 19
Puck Me Harder, Captain
For a second, his expression changed.
Nooked away.
55 vouchers
I didn’t want to know what he was thinking when he looked at me like that but I wasn’t about to find out.
Then he looked back at Matt.
“What are you doing here?”
His voice wasn’t rude. If anything, he sounded genuinely confused.
“Checking on her,” Matt answered.
Logan’s jaw tightened again, and he nodded. “Okay thanks but I can take it from here.”
“I don’t think she wants to talk to you right now,” Matt said.
Logan didn’t look at him. His eyes went straight to me.
“Is that true?”
I couldn’t answer.
Why couldn’t I just say yes?
I knew I didn’t want to talk to him. At least, I thought I didn’t. But saying it out loud felt different, like once I said it, I would have to deal with everything that came after.
Matt looked at me, then back at Logan. He seemed to understand without needing me to say anything.
“I’ll leave.” He stood and leaned slightly toward me. “Text me if you need me.”
I nodded.
Logan waited until the door closed behind him before looking back at me.
Neither of us said anything.
I kept my eyes down, suddenly very aware of how swollen they probably were and how awful I must have looked after crying over something that was supposed to be fake.
Seriously, how was I even supposed to explain this to him?
“Julie,” he said softly. “I’m really sorry.”
I looked up at him, a part of me wondering if he was saying it because he’d seen me crying or because he really had slept with Alia. Either way, I didn’t want to know.
“Can we please have this conversation later?” I asked quietly. “I don’t want you to see me like this.”
Something in his expression changed. “Like what?”
I looked away again.
Puck Me Harder, Captain
“Weak.” The word barely made it past my lips.
e took a step closer to me stopping before he came too close.
“You’re not weak.”
55
55 vouchers
I wanted to believe him, but I couldn’t forget that he’d called me weak before. Maybe that was why his words didn’t feel true now, no matter how much I wanted them to.
I let out a heavy sigh. “You don’t have to lie to me. And I know I shouldn’t even be feeling like this,” I said quietly.
“Julie.”
“It isn’t real, Logan. The relationship is fake, and I know that.” I swallowed, trying to keep my voice from shaking again. “So just… act like you didn’t see me like this.”
He shook his head. “No.”
I looked at him. “No?”
“I’m not going to pretend.”
I didn’t know what to say to that.
He paused for a moment before continuing. “And you have every right to feel the way you feel.”
I swallowed hard.
“Because as long as we’re doing this, as long as we’re together… it’s real,” he said. “And I’m committed to you. Whatever happened with Alia…” His jaw tightened. “I don’t know how she ended up in that room, but I swear to you, I didn’t sleep with her.”
“I saw you with her, Logan.”
“I know but….”
“And after everything those girls said last night…”
The words caught in my throat as everything came rushing back. The way they had talked about having sex with him, the things they claimed he had done with them, the way they laughed about how he never stayed with anyone for long.

Comments
The readers' comments on the novel: Puck Me Harder, Captain (Julie and Logan)
Any updates????...