Login via

Puck Me Harder, Captain (Julie and Logan) novel Chapter 74

74: You Deserve Better

JULIE’S POV

55 vouchers

“It shouldn’t hurt. This wasn’t a real relationship. Logan can do whatever he wants. He can sleep with whoever he wants. He doesn’t owe me any loyalty.”

I had been telling myself that since I left the villa, hoping that if I repeated it enough, eventually it would start to feel true.

It hadn’t.

5

When I got home, I was exhausted from crying. My phone had been ringing and buzzing all morning, but I couldn’t bring myself to look at it. I already knew what was probably waiting for me. Everyone had seen what happened, and by now, the entire internet probably had something to say about it.

I promised myself I wouldn’t cry again, but my eyes started burning almost immediately, and I barely made it a minute before the tears came anyway.

I didn’t know what hurt more, seeing Logan with Alia after I had trusted him enough to believe he wouldn’t do something like that, or knowing that everyone had warned me and I had still chosen not to listen.

“You do not belong in his world, Julie.”

“Logan isn’t a committed person.”

“He’s never been in a relationship before.”

They had all tried to tell me, but I ignored them anyway. I should have listened. I should have known better.

Instead, I was sitting in Logan’s apartment, crying over a relationship that was supposed to be fake.

The doorbell pulled me out of my thoughts.

I quickly wiped my face, as if that would somehow make me look less miserable. It didn’t.

The bell rang again, followed by a familiar voice.

“Julie, it’s Matt.”

My brows pulled together.

Matt? What was he doing here?

I looked at my reflection in the mirror before opening the door. I looked terrible. My eyes were swollen, my nose was red, and my cheeks still had tear stains on them. I tried wiping them away one more time, but it only made me look worse.

Great.

Matt had seen me at my worst before, so I supposed there was no point pretending I was fine now.

14:53 Sat, Sep 19 T

Puck Me Harder, Captain

55 vouchers

I took a long breath, walked to the door, and opened it halfway, peeking through the gap.

He smiled when he saw me.

“Hey. You didn’t grab breakfast, so I thought I’d bring you some bagels with cream cheese and olives.”

My favorite.

He remembered.

For some reason, that made my throat tighten.

“Thanks, Matt, but…” I glanced down. “I’m not really hungry right now.”

My stomach chose that moment to growl.

Matt looked down at the bag in his hand and then back at me.

“Well, I am.”

I let out a tired sigh. “Matt.”

“Okay, fine.” He smiled again. “I actually came to check on you, and I’m not leaving until I do. So can you please open the door?”

I hesitated for a moment before opening it wider.

I stepped aside, and Matt walked in, looking around the apartment.

“Nice place,” he said. “Although you could really use some color in here.”

I nudged him, and he chuckled as he set the bag of bagels on the kitchen counter.

“Okay, I’m starving. Let’s get to eating,” he said, rubbing his hands together.

I looked at him, confused, and he shrugged.

“I did come to check on you, but I’m also hungry.”

He walked into the kitchen and started opening the cupboards, and I knew exactly what Matt was doing. He wasn’t really hungry. He was trying to make things feel normal again, and somehow, that made me want to smile.

“I don’t want to disturb you, but where the hell are the damn plates?”

“Top cupboard,” I said, pointing toward it.

“Who the heck keeps plates there?”

Apparently, Logan Carter.

Matt pulled out the plates, served me some bagel and coffee, and carried everything to the dining table while he stayed by the counter to serve himself. He took a big bite of his bagel before looking over at me, probably expecting me to do the same, but I still hadn’t touched mine.

5

14:53 Sat, Sep 19 TO

Puck Me Harder, Captain

E55 vouchers

I really wasn’t hungry. My stomach might have disagreed, but I couldn’t imagine eating anything right now, and I definitely didn’t have the energy to pretend I was enjoying it.

Matt eventually walked over and sat in the chair beside mine. He stayed quiet for a while before looking at

“Okay, let’s talk.”

I lifted my gaze to him. “Okay,” I said carefully.

He opened his mouth to speak, then closed it almost immediately. His eyes moved from me to the bagel sitting untouched in front of me and back again, like he was trying to figure out where to start.

“Okay, so I actually didn’t think about what we should talk about.”

That made me laugh a little.

Matt smiled when he heard it and leaned a little closer. “You’re a really great person, Julie. You know that, right?”

I couldn’t answer. Right now, I wasn’t sure I believed that myself.

“And whatever Logan did, it doesn’t change what you’re worth.”

I looked at him slowly. “Really?”

He nodded. “Yeah.”

I looked down at my bagel, but a small smile still found its way onto my face. I didn’t know why his words were getting to me so much, but suddenly my eyes started burning again.

I looked away quickly, hoping he wouldn’t notice.

Quick check to keep reading. It usually passes on its own.

Reading History

No history.

Comments

The readers' comments on the novel: Puck Me Harder, Captain (Julie and Logan)