Chapter 75
Elara
He slid a document across the table. “This is a temporary restraining
order requiring you to immediately cease all defamatory behavior,
including but not limited to spreading false information on social
media, in public, or in private.”
I took a breath. “Everything I showed was real. The signature E.C., the
date from 2015, the Italian notations, the handwritten notes on the
back–those are facts.”
Sterling’s smile was cold. “Facts? Ms. Kennedy has publicly explained
that E.C. is her pseudonym, Elena Celeste.”
“But those sketches are dated 2015. Sloane was only fifteen then. How
could she create a painting dedicated to ‘Julian‘ when you weren’t
even together yet?”
Brief silence.
Sloane spoke, voice trembling. “Elara… I know this is hard to believe, but those really are my works. I was fourteen when I attended a
summer art program in Florence. That’s where I first met Julian. I fell
1/8
Chapter 75
in love at first sight. The painting began then, but I only recently
completed it for this lecture–it’s been a long creative process.”
Her eyes welled with tears. “And ‘Per la memoria di‘… it doesn’t only
mean ‘in memory of the deceased.‘ In Italian, it can also express ‘to
remember someone.‘ I wanted to remember the inspiration and love
Julian gave me.”
A few sympathetic murmurs rippled through the room.
Ice crawled up my spine. The lie was perfect–every detail, every
timeline inconsistency, smoothly explained away.
Sterling pressed on. “Ms. Kennedy has provided adequate explanation.
The question is: how did you obtain these private sketches? These
photographs are Ms. Kennedy’s personal property. Your unauthorized
distribution constitutes invasion of privacy.”
“I got them from my mother. These sketches belonged to Mrs.
Castellano-”
“Mrs. Castellano?” Sterling interrupted. “Can you prove this person
existed?”
“She was real! She died three years ago. I have her obituary, her
studio address-”
218
Chapter 75
“Information that can be fabricated. Can you provide her birth
certificate, social security number, official identity documents?”
I froze. I had none of those. Mrs. Castellano was an Italian
immigrant; mai., records had been lost when her landlord cleared out
her apartment after her death.
Sterling seized the opening. “You see–you cannot prove this ‘Mrs.
Castellano‘ ever existed. Meanwhile, Ms. Kennedy has provided
substantial evidence that E.C. is her pseudonym.”
He displayed a series of documents: photos of teenage Sloane at a
Florence art academy, a sketchbook signed “E.C.” (obviously recently
fabricated but convincingly aged), a letter from an “art program
instructor” (forged, but official–looking).
Mr. Harrington looked at me. “Ms. Vance, the evidence appears
unfavorable to you. Do you have anything to add?”
I knew it was pointless. They could twist any evidence I offered.
Sterling opened another folder. “Ms. Vance, given the severe harm
your malicious accusations have caused my client, we require the
following remediation: First, you must immediately post a public apology on social media, admitting your allegations were completely
false. Second-”
3/8
Chapter 75
“Sterling, wait.” Sloane interrupted him, voice urgent.
Everyone turned.
Sloane stood and walked toward me. A flash of nervousness crossed
her face before dissolving into gentle concern. “Elara… I know you
might have been misled, or perhaps just misunderstood. I don’t want
this to escalate further. It’s not good for either of us.”
She bit her lip, as if making a difficult decision. “The apology…
actually, you don’t have to do it. I don’t want to force you to say
something you don’t believe.”
Surface magnanimity. Underneath: fear. She wasn’t sure what other
evidence I might have. A public apology would keep the spotlight on
the story, potentially triggering more uncontrollable revelations.
Sterling frowned. “Ms. Kennedy-”
“Sterling, I just want this to end quickly. Prolonged conflict isn’t good
for my art.” She turned to me, eyes sincere. “But I do have one
condition. You must sign a written pledge promising not to spread unverified information about my work in any public or private
setting. This protects both of us and avoids legal disputes.”
Her tone was gentle but firm. “If you sign this agreement, we can put
48
Chapter 75
this behind us. I won’t pursue it further, and the school won’t make
things difficult for you.”
Surface compromise. Real goal: silence me quickly before things
spiral.
Sterling glanced at Julian. Julian nodded slightly–understanding
Sloane’s strategy.
Sterling handed me a document. “This is a confidentiality and non-
disclosure agreement. Contents include: you acknowledge yesterday’s
information was misleading; you promise not to spread questions
about Ms. Kennedy’s work origins in any form; violation carries a
penalty of no less than $500,000 plus full legal liability.”
My fingers trembled as I took the pages.
I scanned the terms. This agreement would seal my mouth. Once
signed, I could never publicly discuss Sloane’s plagiarism again,
But I’d also caught Sloane’s nervousness–that too–quick “the apology
can be waived,” the flicker in her eyes that revealed uncertainty.
“What if I don’t sign?”
Sloane’s face stiffened briefly before recovering. “Then I can only
5/8
Chapter 75
respect Sterling’s recommendation and resolve this through legal
channels. But I really hope it doesn’t come to that…”
VERIFYCAPTCHA_LABEL
Comments
The readers' comments on the novel: Reborn at Eighteen The Billionaire's Second Chance