Since the divorce, Isabella never smiled when she saw Ethan anymore. At least, never in front of him.
But with Harold, she was different. She laughed, her eyes full of light.
That was proof enough of how much she couldn’t stand Ethan now.
He knew he’d messed up. He knew it better than anyone. But he was trying to change, really trying. Wasn’t it fair to hope for just one chance to make things right? To start over?
Ethan watched from a distance, unable to bring himself to interrupt her happiness. For now, he just stood there, silent.
Nadine, though, didn’t hesitate. She walked right over.
She had always liked Harold. Her family wasn’t as powerful as his, but they were still well-off, otherwise she wouldn’t have gotten an invite to this party. She and Natalie were best friends. Through Natalie and Ethan, she’d met Harold. It wasn’t love at first sight. It was the kind of feeling that grew slowly, the more she saw who Harold really was.
He was responsible, smart, and from a good family. He was set to inherit everything from the Carters.
So, little by little, Nadine fell for him.
She’d confessed once, heart pounding, but Harold turned her down.
Back then, Isabella and Ethan were still married. Harold kept his distance from Isabella. They hardly ever saw each other. No one would have guessed Harold liked Isabella, not even Nadine.
After getting rejected, Nadine blamed herself. Maybe she just wasn’t good enough. So she tried harder, pushing herself to be better, to be kinder to Harold and everyone in the Carter family. She hoped that if she kept at it, one day she might finally matter to Harold.
But as soon as Ethan and Isabella broke up, something changed. Harold didn’t hide his feelings anymore. He started chasing after Isabella, treating her gently, sending flowers, picking her up and dropping her off at work. Whenever Isabella needed help, Harold was there before anyone else.
“Harold, it’s just one dance. Won’t you do me this favor?” Nadine kept her smile, pretending not to notice his coldness. She turned to Isabella, her voice a little too sweet. “Isabella, can I borrow Harold for just one dance? I’ll give him back right after. Is that okay?”
Isabella’s answer was calm. “Nadine, Harold’s a grown man. If he wants to dance with you, that’s up to him. I can’t make that decision for him, so you don’t need my permission.”
“But he won’t agree! Isabella, please, just talk to him for me. It’s only a dance.”
“I’m sorry, Nadine. This is between you and Harold. He can decide for himself. If you want to dance, just ask him.”
“Isabella…”
“Nadine.” Harold’s voice was sharp now, his face cold. “I already said I’m not dancing. Please stop interrupting. Let Isabella and me talk. And don’t put her on the spot. Who I dance with is up to me.”

Comments
The readers' comments on the novel: After I Stopped Loving Him (Isabella and Ethan)
Author, please get your characters names right. You always messing them up!...
I wish Harold will win Isabella's heart. I was so sad when Isabela was taken for granted coldly and cruelly by her supposed to be husband, and trapped,mocked and humiliated non stop by Natalie. This was so cruel, both don't deserve Isabela' forgiveness I wish for a happy ending between Isabela and Harold, he has the right to be happy after the long wait....
Frankly, the story initially was going quite good and the pacing was just right. unfortunately after Ethan got the dream of his past life, the story has been going in circles. Ethan's spouting the same nonsense every time he sees Isabella, they both have same conversations over and over. The authors monologue too has been the same for almost 400 chapters. Irrespective of which character the writing the just a repetition of what someone had gone through in the past and what made a certain character feel the emotions. York got introduced in 800 chapters yet nothing significant happened till date. Isabella is soft with Harold and kind of disgusted with Ethan, yet it is not entirely clear with whom she might end up. If she stays single i am fine with it but the story is clearly about Isabella and Ethan so almost 1000 chapters without seeing any progress in their relationship is frustrating. Except for being blindly in love and few aggressive instances with Isabella, Ethan actually isnt a bad person so i am fine if he can win her back. Even though Harold is coming off as a good second lead, i am somehow unable to warm upto him. Even the bad people in the story are not really facing any real consequences. I hate Jackson for his hypocrisy. I hate Jordan and Natalie for their self-righteouness and selfishness. I also hate Deborah, except when she is handing it out to Natalie. I am almost on the verge of dropping this story....
Why are they acting like kids 🤣😭...
Ethan is actually not that bad if we take out his blind love for Natalie...